Review 1 for Leipold et al. 2026

Gutachten vom 29.10.2026

Recommended citation: Jens Bemme: Review for Frieder Leipold / Lily Baumeister / Isabella Limmer / Miriam Siebert / Max Kristen / Chiara Franceschini: Mapping Hospital Heritage with WikiFAIR. A Proposal for Research Data Management. In: Zeitschrift für digitale Geisteswissenschaften. 29.10.2026. DOI: 10.17175/2026_008_r1

Content and Organization / Structure of the Article

☑ Clear hypotheses are presented.
☑ The topic is meaningfully limited.
☐ The methods used are adequately presented.
☐ The author(s) reflect(s) upon her / his / their own methodological approach.
☐ There is a comprehensible and transparent line of reasoning.
☐ The stated goals are reached.
☐ The current state of research is adequately included.

★★☆☆☆☆☆
Quality of article content
Excellent work and a significant contribution
★★★★★
Importance for theory and practice
Relevant
★★★★☆
Originality and innovativeness
Pioneering
★★★★☆
Quality of the presentation (structure, language, style)
Well-written
★★★★☆
Overall evaluation of the article submission

Definitely accept (very high quality)

Ampel auf gruen
Concluding summary

Thank you for the opportunity to review your paper. It describes a strong approach for an open research data management framework for a collaborative study and research design with FAIR linked open data for an underrated topic: the study of the visual culture of hospitals with Wikidata. You address the multiple advantages of Wikidata.

I wonder if the institutional metadata in Wikidata of relevant archives or other GLAM institutions with relevant sources for the ARCHIATER project could be involved and visualised as well as additional research data in this paper or in a following publication. (Given that such institutional metadata often still lack sufficient data quality or statements.) This could be a starting point to involve crowdsourcing activities for additional FAIR data improvements for example with the Wikimedia movement and specific communities of Wikimedians.

Suggestions for improvement / recommended revisions

See above.

Finally: If you plan to catalogue your paper in Wikidata, you could insert its new (Qid) in your paper in advance as a note.