14 | Lizenz: Sofern nicht anders angegeben
| 17 | Version 2.0: 23.07.2021
|
---|
15 |
| | |
---|
16 |
| | |
---|
17 | Medienlizenzen: Medienrechte liegen bei den Autoren
| | |
---|
18 |
| | |
---|
19 | Letzte Überprüfung aller Verweise: 27.11.2019
| | |
---|
20 |
| | |
---|
21 | GND-Verschlagwortung: Gefühl | Hermeneutik | Literaturwissenschaft | Netzwerkanalyse (Soziologie) | Textanalyse |
| | |
---|
22 |
| | |
---|
23 | Empfohlene Zitierweise: Evgeny Kim, Roman Klinger: A Survey on Sentiment and Emotion Analysis for Computational Literary Studies. In: Zeitschrift für digitale Geisteswissenschaften. Wolfenbüttel 2019. text/html Format. DOI: 10.17175/2019_008
| | |
---|
24 |
| | |
---|
25 |
| | |
---|
26 |
| | |
---|
27 |
| | |
---|
28 |
| | |
---|
29 | Abstract
| | |
---|
30 | Emotions are a crucial part of compelling narratives: literature tells us about
| | |
---|
31 | people with goals, desires, passions, and intentions. In the past, the
| | |
---|
32 | affective dimension of literature was mainly studied in the context of literary
| | |
---|
33 | hermeneutics. However, with the emergence of the research field known as
| | |
---|
34 | Digital Humanities (DH), some studies of emotions in a literary context have
| | |
---|
35 | taken a computational turn. Given the fact that DH is still being formed as a
| | |
---|
36 | field, this direction of research can be rendered relatively new. In this
| | |
---|
37 | survey, we offer an overview of the existing body of research on sentiment and
| | |
---|
38 | emotion analysis as applied to literature. The research under review deals with
| | |
---|
39 | a variety of topics including tracking dramatic changes of a plot development,
| | |
---|
40 | network analysis of a literary text, and understanding the emotionality of
| | |
---|
41 | texts, among other topics.
| | |
---|
42 |
| | |
---|
43 |
| | |
---|
44 |
| | |
---|
45 |
| | |
---|
46 | Emotionen sind ein wichtiger Bestandteil überzeugender Erzählungen,
| | |
---|
47 | Literatur beschreibt schließlich Menschen und ihre Ziele, Wünsche,
| | |
---|
48 | Leidenschaften und Absichten. In der Vergangenheit wurde diese affektive
| | |
---|
49 | Dimension hauptsächlich im Rahmen der literarischen Hermeneutik
| | |
---|
50 | untersucht. Mit dem Aufkommen des Forschungsfeldes Digital Humanities
| | |
---|
51 | (DH) wurde jedoch in einigen Studien bezüglich des Aspekts der Emotionen
| | |
---|
52 | im literarischen Kontext eine Wende hin zu komputationellen Methoden
| | |
---|
53 | vorgenommen. Diese Forschungsrichtung ist aktuell durch die Prozesse in
| | |
---|
54 | den DH in einer Neugestaltung. In diesem Artikel berichten wir über den aktuellen
| | |
---|
55 | Forschungsstand zur
| | |
---|
56 | Sentiment- und Emotionsanalyse zur Analyse von Literatur. Wir behandeln
| | |
---|
57 | eine Vielzahl von Themen, wie zum Beispiel die Veränderungen der
| | |
---|
58 | emotionalen Konnotation im Verlauf eines Texts, der Netzwerkanalyse
| | |
---|
59 | eines literarischen Textes und dem Verständnis der Emotionalität von Texten.
| | |
---|
60 |
| | |
---|
61 |
| | |
---|
62 |
| | |
---|
63 | Zu diesem Artikel ist eine überarbeitete Version erschienen: Version 2
| | |
---|
64 |
| | |
---|
65 |
| | |
---|
66 | 1 Introduction and Motivation
| | |
---|
67 | 1.1 Emotions and Arts
| | |
---|
68 | 2 Affect and Emotion
| | |
---|
69 | 2.1 Ekman’s Theory of Basic Emotions
| | |
---|
70 | 2.2 Plutchik’s Wheel of Emotions
| | |
---|
71 | 2.3 Russel’s Circumplex Model
| | |
---|
72 | 3 Emotion Analysis in Non-computational Literary Studies
| | |
---|
73 | 4 Emotion and Sentiment Analysis in Computational Literary Studies
| | |
---|
74 | 4.1 Emotion Classification
| | |
---|
75 | 4.1.1 Classification based on emotions
| | |
---|
76 | 4.1.2 Classification of happy ending vs. non-happy endings
| | |
---|
77 | 4.2 Genre and Story-type Classification
| | |
---|
78 | 4.2.1 Story-type clustering
| | |
---|
79 | 4.2.2 Genre classification
| | |
---|
80 | 4.3 Temporal Change of Sentiment
| | |
---|
81 | 4.3.1 Topography of emotions
| | |
---|
82 | 4.3.2 Tracking sentiment
| | |
---|
83 | 4.3.3 Sentiment recognition in historical texts
| | |
---|
84 | 4.4 Character Network Analysis and Relationship Extraction
| | |
---|
85 | 4.4.1 Sentiment dynamics between characters
| | |
---|
86 | 4.4.2 Character analysis and character relationships
| | |
---|
87 | 4.5 Other Types of Emotion Analysis
| | |
---|
88 | 4.5.1 Emotion flow analysis and visualization
| | |
---|
89 | 4.5.2 Miscellaneous
| | |
---|
90 | 5 Discussion and Conclusion
| | |
---|
91 | Acknowledgements
| | |
---|
92 | Bibliographic References
| | |
---|
93 | List of Figures with Captions
| | |
---|
94 |
| | |
---|
95 |
| | |
---|
96 | 1 Introduction and Motivation
| | |
---|
97 |
| | |
---|
98 | This article deals with emotion and sentiment analysis in computational literary studies.
| | |
---|
99 | Following Liu[1], we define sentiment as a
| | |
---|
100 | positive or negative feeling
| | |
---|
101 | underlying the opinion. The term opinion in this sense is
| | |
---|
102 | close to attitude in psychology and both sentiment analysis
| | |
---|
103 | and opinion mining are often used interchangeably. Sentiment analysis is an area of
| | |
---|
104 | computational linguistics that analyzes people’s sentiments and opinions regarding
| | |
---|
105 | different objects or topics. Though sentiment analysis is primarily text-oriented,
| | |
---|
106 | there are multimodal approaches as well.[2]
| | |
---|
107 | Defining the concept of emotion is a challenging task. As
| | |
---|
108 | Scherer puts it, defining emotion is a notorious problem.[3] Indeed, different methodological and conceptual
| | |
---|
109 | approaches to dealing with emotions lead to different definitions. However, the
| | |
---|
110 | majority of emotion theorists agree that emotions involve a set of expressive,
| | |
---|
111 | behavioral, physiological, and phenomenological features.[4] In this view, an emotion can be defined as an
| | |
---|
112 | integrated feeling state involving physiological changes, motor-preparedness,
| | |
---|
113 | cognitions about action, and inner experiences that emerges from an appraisal of the
| | |
---|
114 | self or situation.[5]
| | |
---|
115 | Similar to sentiment, emotions can be analyzed computationally. However, the goal
| | |
---|
116 | of
| | |
---|
117 | emotion analysis is to recognize the emotion, rather than sentiment, which makes it
| | |
---|
118 | a
| | |
---|
119 | more difficult task as differences between emotions are subtler than those between
| | |
---|
120 | positive and negative.
| | |
---|
121 |
| | |
---|
122 | Although sentiment and emotion analysis are different tasks, our review of the
| | |
---|
123 | literature shows that the use of either term is not always consistent. There are
| | |
---|
124 | cases where researchers analyze only positive and negative aspects of a text but
| | |
---|
125 | refer to their analysis as emotion analysis. Likewise, there are cases where
| | |
---|
126 | researchers look into a set of subjective feelings including emotions but call it
| | |
---|
127 | sentiment analysis. Hence, to avoid confusion, in this survey, we use the terms emotion analysis and sentiment analysis
| | |
---|
128 | interchangeably. In most cases, we follow the terminology used by the authors of the
| | |
---|
129 | papers we discuss (i.e., if they call emotions sentiments, we do the same).
| | |
---|
130 |
| | |
---|
131 | Finally, we talk about sentiment and emotion analysis in the context of computational
| | |
---|
132 | literary studies. Da defines computational literary studies as the statistical
| | |
---|
133 | representation of patterns discovered in text mining fitted to currently existing
| | |
---|
134 | knowledge about literature, literary history, and textual production.[6] Computational literary studies are
| | |
---|
135 | synonymous to distant reading[7] and digital
| | |
---|
136 | literary studies,[8]
| | |
---|
137 | each of which refers to the practice of running a textual analysis on a computer to
| | |
---|
138 | yield quantitative results. In this survey, we use all of these terms interchangeably
| | |
---|
139 | and when we refer to digital humanities as a field, we refer to those groups of
| | |
---|
140 | researchers whose primary objects of study are texts.
| | |
---|
141 |
| | |
---|
142 |
| | |
---|
143 | 1.1 Emotions and Arts
| | |
---|
144 |
| | |
---|
145 | Much of our daily experiences influence and are influenced by the emotions we
| | |
---|
146 | experience.[9] This experience is
| | |
---|
147 | not limited to real events. People can feel emotions because they are reading a novel
| | |
---|
148 | or watching a play or a movie.[10] There is a growing
| | |
---|
149 | body of literature that pinpoints the importance of emotions for literary comprehension,
| | |
---|
150 | [11] as well as research
| | |
---|
151 | that recognizes the deliberate choices people make with regard to their emotional
| | |
---|
152 | states when seeking narrative enjoyment such as a book or a film[12]
| | |
---|
153 | The link between emotions and arts in general is a matter of debate that dates back
| | |
---|
154 | to the Ancient period, particularly to Plato, who viewed passions and desires as the
| | |
---|
155 | lowest kind of knowledge and treated poets as undesirable members in his ideal
| | |
---|
156 | society.[13] In contrast, Aristotle’s
| | |
---|
157 | view on emotive components of poetry expressed in his Poetics[14] differed from Plato’s in that
| | |
---|
158 | emotions do have great importance, particularly in the moral life of a person.[15] In the late nineteenth
| | |
---|
159 | century the emotion theory of arts stepped into the spotlight of philosophers. One
| | |
---|
160 | of
| | |
---|
161 | the first accounts on the topic is given by Leo Tolstoy in 1898 in his essay What is Art?.[16] Tolstoy argues that art
| | |
---|
162 | can express emotions experienced in fictitious context and the degree to which the
| | |
---|
163 | audience is convinced of them defines the success of the artistic work.[17]
| | |
---|
164 | New methods of quantitative research emerged in humanities scholarship bringing forth
| | |
---|
165 | the so-called digital revolution[18] and the transformation of the
| | |
---|
166 | field into what we know as digital humanities.[19] The adoption of computational
| | |
---|
167 | methods of text analysis and data mining from the fields of then fast-growing areas
| | |
---|
168 | of computational linguistics and artificial intelligence provided humanities scholars
| | |
---|
169 | with new tools of text analytics and data-driven approaches to theory
| | |
---|
170 | formulation.[20]
| | |
---|
171 | To the best of our knowledge, the first work[21] on a computer-assisted modeling of emotions in
| | |
---|
172 | literature appeared in 1982. Challenged by the question of why some texts are more
| | |
---|
173 | interesting than others, Anderson and McMaster concluded that the emotional tone of
| | |
---|
174 | a
| | |
---|
175 | story can be responsible for the reader’s interest. The results of their study
| | |
---|
176 | suggest that a large-scale analysis of the emotional tone of a collection of texts
| | |
---|
177 | is
| | |
---|
178 | possible with the help of a computer program. There are two implications of this
| | |
---|
179 | finding. First, they suggested that by identifying emotional tones of text passages
| | |
---|
180 | one can model affective patterns of a given text or a collection of texts, which in
| | |
---|
181 | turn can be used to challenge or test existing literary theories. Second, their
| | |
---|
182 | approach to affect modeling demonstrates that the stylistic properties of texts can
| | |
---|
183 | be defined on the basis of their emotional interest and not only their linguistic
| | |
---|
184 | characteristics. With regard to these implications, this work is an important early
| | |
---|
185 | piece as it laid out a roadmap for some of the basic applications of sentiment and
| | |
---|
186 | emotion analysis of texts, namely sentiment and emotion pattern recognition from text
| | |
---|
187 | and computational text characterization based on sentiment and emotion.
| | |
---|
188 |
| | |
---|
189 | With the development of research methods used by digital humanities researchers, the
| | |
---|
190 | number of approaches and goals of emotion and sentiment analysis in literature has
| | |
---|
191 | grown. The goal of this survey is to provide an overview of these recent methods of
| | |
---|
192 | emotion and sentiment analysis as applied to a text. The survey is directed at
| | |
---|
193 | researchers looking for an introduction to the existing research in the field of
| | |
---|
194 | sentiment and emotion analysis of a (primarily, literary) text. The survey does not
| | |
---|
195 | cover applications of emotion and sentiment analysis in the areas of digital
| | |
---|
196 | humanities that are not focused on text. Neither does it provide an in-depth overview
| | |
---|
197 | of all possible applications of emotion analysis in the computational context outside
| | |
---|
198 | of the DH line of research.
| | |
---|
199 |
| | |
---|
200 |
| | |
---|
201 |
| | |
---|
202 |
| | |
---|
203 | 2 Affect and Emotion
| | |
---|
204 |
| | |
---|
205 | The history of emotion research has a long and rich tradition that followed Darwin’s
| | |
---|
206 | 1872 publication of The Expression of the Emotions in Man and Animals[22]. The subject of emotion theories is vast
| | |
---|
207 | and diverse. We refer the reader to Maria Gendron’s paper[23] for a brief history of ideas about emotion
| | |
---|
208 | in psychology. Here, we will focus on three views on emotion that are popular in
| | |
---|
209 | computational analysis of emotions: Ekman’s theory of basic
| | |
---|
210 | emotions, Plutchik’s wheel of emotion, and Russel’s
| | |
---|
211 | circumplex model.
| | |
---|
212 |
| | |
---|
213 |
| | |
---|
214 | 2.1 Ekman’s Theory of Basic Emotions
| | |
---|
215 |
| | |
---|
216 | The basic emotion theory was first articulated by Silvan Tomkins[24] in the early 1960s. Tomkins postulated that each instance
| | |
---|
217 | of a certain emotion is biologically similar to other instances of the same emotion
| | |
---|
218 | or shares a common trigger. One of Tomkins’ mentees, Paul Ekman, put in question the
| | |
---|
219 | existing emotion theories that proclaimed that facial expressions of emotion are
| | |
---|
220 | socially learned and therefore vary from culture to culture. Ekman, Sorenson and
| | |
---|
221 | Friesen challenged this view[25]
| | |
---|
222 | in a field study with the outcome that facial displays of fundamental emotions are
| | |
---|
223 | not learned but innate. However, there are culture-specific prescriptions about how
| | |
---|
224 | and in which situations emotions are displayed.
| | |
---|
225 |
| | |
---|
226 | Based on the observation of facial behavior in early development or social
| | |
---|
227 | interaction, Ekman’s theory also postulates that emotions should be considered discrete categories[26]
| | |
---|
228 | rather than continuous. Though this
| | |
---|
229 | view allows for conceiving of emotions as having different intensities, it does not
| | |
---|
230 | allow emotions to blend and leaves no room for more complex affective states in which
| | |
---|
231 | individuals report the co-occurrence of like-valenced discrete
| | |
---|
232 | emotions.[27] This and other theory
| | |
---|
233 | postulates were widely criticized and disputed in literature.[28]
| | |
---|
234 |
| | |
---|
235 |
| | |
---|
236 | 2.2 Plutchik’s Wheel of Emotions
| | |
---|
237 |
| | |
---|
238 | Another influential model of emotions was proposed by Robert Plutchik in the early
| | |
---|
239 | 1980s.[29] The important difference
| | |
---|
240 | between Plutchik’s theory and Ekman’s theory is that apart from a small set of basic
| | |
---|
241 | emotions, all other emotions are mixed and derived from the various combinations of
| | |
---|
242 | basic ones. He further categorized these other emotions into the primary dyads (very likely to co-occur), secondary
| | |
---|
243 | dyads (less likely to co-occur) and tertiary dyads
| | |
---|
244 | (seldom co-occur).
| | |
---|
245 |
| | |
---|
246 | In order to represent the organization and properties of emotions as defined by his
| | |
---|
247 | theory, Plutchik proposed a structural model of emotions known nowadays as Plutchik’s wheel of emotions. The wheel Figure 1 is constructed in the fashion of a color wheel, with
| | |
---|
248 | similar emotions placed closer together and opposite emotions 180 degrees apart. The
| | |
---|
249 | intensity of an emotion in the wheel depends on how far from the center a part of
| | |
---|
250 | a
| | |
---|
251 | petal is, i.e., emotions become less distinguishable the further they are from the
| | |
---|
252 | center of the wheel. Essentially, the wheel is constructed from eight basic bipolar
| | |
---|
253 | emotions: joy versus sorrow, anger versus fear, trust versus disgust, and surprise versus anticipation. The blank spaces
| | |
---|
254 | between the leaves are so-called primary dyads – emotions that
| | |
---|
255 | are mixtures of two of the primary emotions.
| | |
---|
256 |
| | |
---|
257 | The wheel model of emotions proposed by Plutchik had a great impact on the field of affective computing
| | |
---|
258 | being primarily used as a basis for emotion categorization in emotion recognition
| | |
---|
259 | from text.[30] However, some postulates of the theory are criticized,
| | |
---|
260 | for example, there is no empirical support for the wheel structure.[31] Another criticism is that
| | |
---|
261 | Plutchik’s model of emotion does not explain the mechanisms by which love, hate, relief, pride, and other everyday emotions emerge
| | |
---|
262 | from the basic emotions, nor does it provide reliable
| | |
---|
263 | measurements of these emotions.[32]
| | |
---|
264 |
| | |
---|
265 |
| | |
---|
266 | Fig. 1: Plutchik’s wheel of emotions. [Plutchik 2011.
| | |
---|
267 | PD]
| | |
---|
268 |
| | |
---|
269 |
| | |
---|
270 |
| | |
---|
271 |
| | |
---|
272 | 2.3 Russel’s Circumplex Model
| | |
---|
273 |
| | |
---|
274 | Attempts to overcome the shortcomings of basic emotions theory and its unfitness for
| | |
---|
275 | clinical studies led researchers to suggest various dimensional models, the most
| | |
---|
276 | prominent of which is the circumplex model of affect proposed by James Russel.[33] The word circumplex
| | |
---|
277 | in the name of the model refers to the fact that emotional episodes do not cluster
| | |
---|
278 | at
| | |
---|
279 | the axes but rather at the periphery of a circle Figure 2. At the core of the
| | |
---|
280 | circumplex model is the notion of two dimensions plotted on a circle along horizontal
| | |
---|
281 | and vertical axes. These dimensions are valence (how pleasant
| | |
---|
282 | or unpleasant one feels) and arousal (the degree of calmness
| | |
---|
283 | or excitement). The number of dimensions is not strictly fixed and there are
| | |
---|
284 | adaptations of the model that incorporate more dimensions. One example of this is
| | |
---|
285 | the
| | |
---|
286 | Valence-Arousal-Dominance model that adds an additional
| | |
---|
287 | dimension of dominance, the degree of control one feels over the situation that
| | |
---|
288 | causes an emotion.[34]
| | |
---|
289 | By moving from discrete categories to a dimensional representation, the researchers
| | |
---|
290 | are able to account for subjective experiences that do not fit nicely into the
| | |
---|
291 | isolated non-overlapping categories. Accordingly, each affective experience can be
| | |
---|
292 | depicted as a point in a circumplex that is described by only
| | |
---|
293 | two parameters – valence and arousal –
| | |
---|
294 | without need for labeling or reference to emotion concepts for which a name might
| | |
---|
295 | only exist in particular subcommunities or which are difficult to describe.[35] However, the strengths of the model turned
| | |
---|
296 | out to be its weaknesses: for example, it is not clear whether there are basic
| | |
---|
297 | dimensions in the model[36] nor is it
| | |
---|
298 | clear what should be done with qualitatively different events of fear, anger, embarrassment and
| | |
---|
299 | disgust that fall in identical places in the circumplex
| | |
---|
300 | structure.[37] Despite these
| | |
---|
301 | shortcomings, the circumplex model of affect is widely used in psychologic and
| | |
---|
302 | psycholinguistic studies. In computational linguistics, the circumplex model is
| | |
---|
303 | applied when the interest is in continuous measurements of valence and arousal rather than in the specific
| | |
---|
304 | discrete emotional categories.
| | |
---|
305 |
| | |
---|
306 |
| | |
---|
307 |
| | |
---|
308 | Fig. 2: Circumplex model of affect: Horizontal axis represents the valence dimension,
| | |
---|
309 | the vertical axis represents the arousal dimension. Drawn after Posner et al. 2005. [Kim / Klinger 2019]
| | |
---|
310 |
| | |
---|
311 |
| | |
---|
312 |
| | |
---|
313 |
| | |
---|
314 | 3 Emotion Analysis in Non-computational Literary Studies
| | |
---|
315 |
| | |
---|
316 | Until the end of the twentieth century, literary and art theories often disregarded
| | |
---|
317 | the importance of the aesthetic and affective dimension of literature, which in part
| | |
---|
318 | stemmed from the rejection of old-fashioned literary history that had explained the
| | |
---|
319 | meaning of art works by the biography of the author.[38] However, the affective turn taken by a wide range of
| | |
---|
320 | disciplines in the past two decades – from political and sociological sciences to
| | |
---|
321 | neurosciences or media studies – has refueled the interest of literary critics in
| | |
---|
322 | human affects and sentiments.
| | |
---|
323 |
| | |
---|
324 | We said in Section 1 that there seems to be a consensus among literary critics that
| | |
---|
325 | literary art and emotions go hand in hand. However, one might be challenged to define
| | |
---|
326 | the specific way in which emotions come into play in the text. The exploration of
| | |
---|
327 | this problem is presented by van Meel.[39]
| | |
---|
328 | Underpinning the centrality of human destiny, hopes, and feelings in the themes of
| | |
---|
329 | many artworks – from painting to literature – van Meel explores how emotions are
| | |
---|
330 | involved in the production of arts. Pointing out big differences between the two
| | |
---|
331 | media in their attempts to depict human emotions (painting conveys nonverbal behavior
| | |
---|
332 | directly, but lacks temporal dimensions that novels have and use to describe
| | |
---|
333 | emotions), van Meel provides an analysis of the nonverbal descriptions used by the
| | |
---|
334 | writers to convey their characters’ emotional behavior. Description of visual
| | |
---|
335 | characteristics, van Meel speculates, responds to a fundamental need of a reader to
| | |
---|
336 | build an image of a person and their behavior. Moreover, nonverbal descriptions add
| | |
---|
337 | important information that can in some cases play a crucial hermeneutical role, such
| | |
---|
338 | as in Kafka’s Der Prozess, where the fatal decisions for K. are made clear by gestures rather than
| | |
---|
339 | words. His verdict is not announced, but is implied by the judge who refuses a
| | |
---|
340 | handshake. The same applies to his death sentence that is conveyed to him by his
| | |
---|
341 | executioners playing with a butcher’s knife above his head.
| | |
---|
342 |
| | |
---|
343 | A hermeneutic approach through the lense of emotions is presented by Kuivalainen[40] and provides a detailed analysis of
| | |
---|
344 | linguistic features that contribute to the characters’ emotional involvement in
| | |
---|
345 | Mansfield’s prose. The study shows how, through the extensive use of adjectives,
| | |
---|
346 | adverbs, deictic markers, and orthography, Mansfield steers the reader towards the
| | |
---|
347 | protagonist’s climax. Subtly shifting between psycho-narration and free indirect
| | |
---|
348 | discourse, Mansfield is making use of evaluative and emotive descriptors in
| | |
---|
349 | psycho-narrative sections, often marking the internal discourse with dashes,
| | |
---|
350 | exclamation marks, intensifiers, and repetition that thus trigger an emotional
| | |
---|
351 | climax. Various deictic features introduced in the text are used to pinpoint the
| | |
---|
352 | source of emotions, which helps in creating a picture of characters’ emotional world.
| | |
---|
353 | Verbs (especially in the present tense), adjectives, and adverbs serve the same goal
| | |
---|
354 | in Mansfield’s prose of describing the characters’ emotional world. Going back and
| | |
---|
355 | forth from psycho-narration to free indirect discourse provides Mansfield with a tool
| | |
---|
356 | to point out the significant moments in the protagonists’ lives and establish a
| | |
---|
357 | separation between characters and narration.
| | |
---|
358 |
| | |
---|
359 | Both van Meel’s and Kuivalainen’s works, separated from each other by more than a
| | |
---|
360 | decade, underpin the importance of emotions in the interpretation of characters’
| | |
---|
361 | traits, hopes, and tragedy. Other authors find these connections as well. For
| | |
---|
362 | example, Barton[41] proposes instructional
| | |
---|
363 | approaches to teach school-level readers to interpret character’s emotions and use
| | |
---|
364 | this information for story interpretation. Van Horn[42] shows that understanding characters emotionally or trying to help
| | |
---|
365 | them with their problems made reading and writing more meaningful for middle school
| | |
---|
366 | students.
| | |
---|
367 |
| | |
---|
368 | Emotions in text are often conveyed with emotion-bearing words.[43] At the same time their role in the creation
| | |
---|
369 | and depiction of emotion should not be overestimated. That is, saying that someone
| | |
---|
370 | looked angry or fearful or sad, as well as directly expressing characters’ emotions,
| | |
---|
371 | are not the only ways authors build believable fictional spaces filled with
| | |
---|
372 | characters, action, and emotions. In fact, many novelists strive to express emotions
| | |
---|
373 | indirectly by way of figures of speech or catachresis,[44] first of all because emotional language can be
| | |
---|
374 | ambiguous and vague, and, second, to avoid any allusions to Victorian emotionalism
| | |
---|
375 | and pathos.
| | |
---|
376 |
| | |
---|
377 | How can an author convey emotions indirectly? A book chapter by Hillis Miller in Exploring Text and Emotions[45] seeks the answer to exactly this
| | |
---|
378 | question. Using Conrad’s Nostromo opening scenes as material, Hillis Miller shows how Conrad’s descriptions of
| | |
---|
379 | an imaginary space generate emotions in readers without direct communication of
| | |
---|
380 | emotions. Conrad’s Nostromo opening chapter is an objective description of Sulaco, an imaginary land. The
| | |
---|
381 | description is mainly topographical and includes occasional architectural metaphors,
| | |
---|
382 | but it combines wide expanse with hermetically sealed enclosure, which generates
| | |
---|
383 | depthless emotional detachment[46]. Through the use of present tense, Conrad makes the readers suggest
| | |
---|
384 | that the whole scene is timeless and does not change. The topographical descriptions
| | |
---|
385 | are given in a pure materialist way: there is nothing behind clouds, mountains,
| | |
---|
386 | rocks, and sea that would matter to humankind, not a single feature of the landscape
| | |
---|
387 | is personified, and not a single topographical shape is symbolic. Knowingly or
| | |
---|
388 | unknowingly, Miller argues, by telling the readers what they should see – with no
| | |
---|
389 | deviations from truth – Conrad employs a trope that perfectly matches Kant’s concept of the sublime. Kant’s view of poetry was that true poets tell the truth without
| | |
---|
390 | interpretation; they do not deviate from what their eyes see. Conrad, or to be more
| | |
---|
391 | specific, his narrator in Nostromo, is an example of sublime seeing with a latent presence of strong emotions.
| | |
---|
392 | On the one hand, Conrad’s descriptions are cool and detached. This coolness is caused
| | |
---|
393 | by the indifference of the elements in the scene. On the other hand, by dehumanizing
| | |
---|
394 | sea and sky, Conrad generates awe, fear, and a dark foreboding about the kinds of
| | |
---|
395 | life stories that are likely to be enacted against such a backdrop[47].
| | |
---|
396 |
| | |
---|
397 | Hillis Miller’s analysis resonates with some premises from emotion theory that we
| | |
---|
398 | have discussed previously, namely, Plutchik’s belief that emotions should be studied
| | |
---|
399 | not by a certain way of expression but by the overall behavior of a person.
| | |
---|
400 | Considering that such a formula cannot be applied to all literary theory studies
| | |
---|
401 | about emotions (as not all authors choose to convey emotions indirectly, as well as
| | |
---|
402 | not all authors tend to comment on characters’ nonverbal emotional behavior), it
| | |
---|
403 | seems that one should search for a balance between low-level linguistic feature
| | |
---|
404 | analysis of emotional language and a rigorous high-level hermeneutic inquiry
| | |
---|
405 | dissecting the form of the novel and its under-covered philosophical layers.
| | |
---|
406 |
| | |
---|
407 |
| | |
---|
408 |
| | |
---|
409 | 4 Emotion and Sentiment Analysis in Computational Literary Studies
| | |
---|
410 |
| | |
---|
411 | With this section, we proceed to an overview of the existing body of research on
| | |
---|
412 | computational analysis of emotion and sentiment in computational literary studies.
| | |
---|
413 | An
| | |
---|
414 | overview of the papers including their properties is shown in
| | |
---|
415 | Table 1. The table, as
| | |
---|
416 | well as this section, is divided into several subsections, each of which corresponds
| | |
---|
417 | to a specific application of emotion and sentiment analysis to literature.
| | |
---|
418 | Section 4.1 reviews the papers that deal with the classification of literary texts in terms
| | |
---|
419 | of emotions they convey; Section 4.2 examines the papers that address text
| | |
---|
420 | classification by genre or other story-types based on sentiment and emotion features;
| | |
---|
421 | Section 4.3 is dedicated to research in modeling sentiments and emotions in texts
| | |
---|
422 | from previous centuries, as well as research dealing with applications of sentiment
| | |
---|
423 | analysis to texts written in the past; Section 4.4 provides an overview of sentiment
| | |
---|
424 | analysis applications to character analysis and character network construction, and
| | |
---|
425 | Section 4.5 is dedicated to more general applications of sentiment and emotion
| | |
---|
426 | analysis to literature.
| | |
---|
427 |
| | |
---|
428 |
| | |
---|
429 | 4.1 Emotion Classification
| | |
---|
430 |
| | |
---|
431 | A straightforward approach to sentiment and emotion analysis is phrasing them as a
| | |
---|
432 | text classification[48]. A fundamental
| | |
---|
433 | question of such a classification is how to find the best features and algorithms
| | |
---|
434 | to
| | |
---|
435 | classify the data (sentences, paragraphs, entire documents) into predefined classes.
| | |
---|
436 | When applied to literature, such a classification may be of use for grouping
| | |
---|
437 | different literary texts in digital collections based on the emotional properties
| | |
---|
438 | of
| | |
---|
439 | the stories. For example, books or poems can be grouped based on the emotions they
| | |
---|
440 | convey or based on whether or not they have happy endings or not.
| | |
---|
441 |
| | |
---|
442 |
| | |
---|
443 | 4.1.1 Classification based on emotions
| | |
---|
444 |
| | |
---|
445 | Barros et al.[49] aim at answering two
| | |
---|
446 | research questions: 1) is the classification of Quevedo’s works proposed by the
| | |
---|
447 | literary scholars consistent with the sentiment reflected by the corresponding
| | |
---|
448 | poems?; and 2) which learning algorithms are the best for the classification? To that
| | |
---|
449 | end, they perform a set of experiments on the classification of 185 Francisco de
| | |
---|
450 | Quevedo’s poems that are divided by literary scholars into four categories and that
| | |
---|
451 | Barros et al. map to emotions of joy, anger, fear, and sadness.
| | |
---|
452 | Using the terms joy, anger, fear, and sadness as points of
| | |
---|
453 | reference, Barros et al. construct a list of emotion words by looking up the synonyms
| | |
---|
454 | of English emotion words and adjectives associated with these four emotions and
| | |
---|
455 | translating them into Spanish. Each poem is converted into a vector where each item
| | |
---|
456 | is a normalized count of words relating to a certain emotion. The experiments with
| | |
---|
457 | different algorithms show the superiority of decision trees achieving accuracy of
| | |
---|
458 | almost 60%. However, this result is biased by an unbalanced distribution of classes.
| | |
---|
459 | To avoid the bias, Barros et al. apply a resampling strategy that leads to a more
| | |
---|
460 | balanced distribution and repeat the classification experiments. After resampling,
| | |
---|
461 | the accuracy of decision trees in a 10-fold cross validation achieves 75,13%, thus
| | |
---|
462 | demonstrating an improvement over the previous classification performance. Based on
| | |
---|
463 | these results the authors conclude that a meaningful classification of the literary
| | |
---|
464 | pieces based only on the emotion information is possible.
| | |
---|
465 |
| | |
---|
466 | Reed[50] offers a proof-of-concept for performing sentiment analysis on a corpus of
| | |
---|
467 | twentieth-century American poetry. Specifically, Reed analyzes the expression of
| | |
---|
468 | emotions in the poetry of the Black Arts Movement of the 1960s
| | |
---|
469 | and 1970s. The paper describes the project Measured Unrest in the Poetry of the Black
| | |
---|
470 | Arts Movement whose goal is to understand 1) how the feelings associated with
| | |
---|
471 | injustice are coded in terms of race and gender, and 2) what sentiment analysis can
| | |
---|
472 | show us about the relations between affect and gender in poetry. Reed notes that
| | |
---|
473 | surface affective value of the words does not always align with their more nuanced
| | |
---|
474 | affective meaning shaped by poetic, social, and political contexts.
| | |
---|
475 |
| | |
---|
476 | Yu[51] explores what linguistic patterns
| | |
---|
477 | characterize the genre of sentimentalism in early American novels. To that end, they
| | |
---|
478 | construct a collection of five novels from the mid-nineteenth century and annotate
| | |
---|
479 | the emotionality of each of the chapters as high or low. The respective chapters are then classified using
| | |
---|
480 | support-vector machines and naïve Bayes classifiers as highly emotional or the
| | |
---|
481 | opposite. The results of the evaluation suggest that arbitrary feature reduction
| | |
---|
482 | steps such as stemming and stopword removal should be taken very carefully, as they
| | |
---|
483 | may affect the prediction. For example, Yu shows that no stemming leads to better
| | |
---|
484 | classification results. A possible explanation is that stemming conflates and
| | |
---|
485 | neutralizes a large number of discriminative features. The author provides an example
| | |
---|
486 | of such a conflation with the words wilderness and wild. While the latter can appear anywhere in the text, the
| | |
---|
487 | former one is primarily encountered in the chapters filled with emotions.
| | |
---|
488 |
| | |
---|
489 |
| | |
---|
490 |
| | |
---|
491 | 4.1.2 Classification of happy ending vs. non-happy endings
| | |
---|
492 |
| | |
---|
493 | Zehe et al.[52] argue that automatically
| | |
---|
494 | recognizing a happy ending as a major plot element could help to better understand
| | |
---|
495 | a
| | |
---|
496 | plot structure as a whole. To show that this is possible, they classify 212 German
| | |
---|
497 | novels written between 1750 and 1920 as having happy or non-happy endings. A novel
| | |
---|
498 | is
| | |
---|
499 | considered to have a happy ending if the situation of the main characters in the
| | |
---|
500 | novel improves towards the end or is constantly favorable. The novels were manually
| | |
---|
501 | annotated with this information by domain experts. For feature extraction, the
| | |
---|
502 | authors first split each novel into n segments of the same
| | |
---|
503 | length. They then calculate sentiment values for each of the segments by counting
| | |
---|
504 | the
| | |
---|
505 | occurrences of words that appear in the respective segment and that are found in the
| | |
---|
506 | German version of the NRC Word-Emotion Association Lexicon[53] and divide this number by the
| | |
---|
507 | length of the dictionary. Finally, they calculate the sentiment score for the
| | |
---|
508 | sections by taking the average of all sentiment scores in the segments that are part
| | |
---|
509 | of the section. These steps are then followed by classification with a support-vector
| | |
---|
510 | machine and the F1 score of 0.73, which the authors consider a good starting point
| | |
---|
511 | for future work.
| | |
---|
512 |
| | |
---|
513 |
| | |
---|
514 |
| | |
---|
515 |
| | |
---|
516 | 4.2 Genre and Story-type Classification
| | |
---|
517 |
| | |
---|
518 | The papers we have discussed so far focus on understanding the emotion associated
| | |
---|
519 | with units of texts. This extracted information can further be used for downstream
| | |
---|
520 | tasks and also for downstream evaluations. We discuss the following downstream
| | |
---|
521 | classification cases here. The papers in this category use sentiment and emotion
| | |
---|
522 | features for a higher-level classification, namely story-type clustering and literary
| | |
---|
523 | genre classification. The assumption behind these works is that different types of
| | |
---|
524 | literary text may show different composition and distribution of emotion vocabulary
| | |
---|
525 | and thus can be classified based on this information. The hypothesis that different
| | |
---|
526 | literary genres convey different emotions stems from common knowledge: we know that
| | |
---|
527 | horror stories instill fear and that mysteries evoke anticipation and anger while romances
| | |
---|
528 | are filled with joy and love. However
| | |
---|
529 | as we will see in this section, the task of automatic classification of these genres
| | |
---|
530 | is not always that straightforward and reliable.
| | |
---|
531 |
| | |
---|
532 |
| | |
---|
533 | 4.2.1 Story-type clustering
| | |
---|
534 |
| | |
---|
535 | Similarly to Zehe et al., Reagan et al.[54] are interested in automatically understanding a plot structure as a
| | |
---|
536 | whole, not limited to a book ending. The inspiration for their work comes from Kurt
| | |
---|
537 | Vonnegut’s lecture on emotional arcs of stories.[55]
| | |
---|
538 | Reagan et al. test the idea that the plot
| | |
---|
539 | of each story can be plotted as an emotional arc, i.e. a time
| | |
---|
540 | series graph, where the x-axis represents a time point in a
| | |
---|
541 | story, and the y-axis represents the events happening to the
| | |
---|
542 | main characters that can be favorable (peaks on a graph) or unfavorable (troughs on
| | |
---|
543 | a
| | |
---|
544 | graph). As Vonnegut puts it, the stories can be grouped by these arcs and the number of such groupings is limited. To test this idea, Reagan
| | |
---|
545 | et al. collect the 1,327 most popular books from the Project Gutenberg.[56] Each book is then split into segments for which
| | |
---|
546 | sentiment scores (happy vs. sad) are
| | |
---|
547 | calculated and compared. The results of the analysis show support for six emotional
| | |
---|
548 | patterns that are shared between subgroupings of the corpus:
| | |
---|
549 |
| | |
---|
550 |
| | |
---|
551 | Rise: the arc starts at a low point and steadily increases towards the end;
| | |
---|
552 | Fall: the arc starts at a high point and steadily decreases towards the end;
| | |
---|
553 | Fall-rise: the arc drops in the middle of the story but increases towards the
| | |
---|
554 | end;
| | |
---|
555 |
| | |
---|
556 | Rise-fall: the arc hits the high point in the middle of the story and decreases
| | |
---|
557 | towards the end;
| | |
---|
558 |
| | |
---|
559 | Rise-fall-rise: the arc fluctuates between high and low points but ends with an
| | |
---|
560 | increase;
| | |
---|
561 |
| | |
---|
562 | Fall-rise-fall: the arc fluctuates between high and low points but ends with a
| | |
---|
563 | decrease.
| | |
---|
564 |
| | |
---|
565 |
| | |
---|
566 | Additionally, Reagan et al. find that Icarus, Oedipus, and Man in the hole arcs are
| | |
---|
567 | the three most popular emotional arcs among readers, based on download counts.
| | |
---|
568 |
| | |
---|
569 |
| | |
---|
570 |
| | |
---|
571 | 4.2.2 Genre classification
| | |
---|
572 |
| | |
---|
573 | There are other studies[57] that are similar in spirit to the work done by
| | |
---|
574 | Reagan. Samothrakis and Fasli examine the hypothesis that different genres clearly
| | |
---|
575 | have different emotion patterns to reliably classify them with machine learning. To
| | |
---|
576 | that end, they collect works of the genres mystery, humor, fantasy, horror, science fiction and western from the Project Gutenberg.
| | |
---|
577 |
| | |
---|
578 | Using WordNet-Affect[58] to
| | |
---|
579 | detect emotion words as categorized by Ekman’s fundamental emotion classes, they
| | |
---|
580 | calculate an emotion score for each sentence in the text. Each work is then
| | |
---|
581 | transformed into six vectors, one for each basic emotion. A random forest classifier
| | |
---|
582 | achieves a classification accuracy of 0.52. This is significantly higher than a
| | |
---|
583 | random baseline, which allows the authors to conclude that such a classification is
| | |
---|
584 | feasible.
| | |
---|
585 |
| | |
---|
586 | A study by Kim et al.[59] originates from
| | |
---|
587 | the same premise as the work by Samothrakis and Fasli but puts emphasis on finding
| | |
---|
588 | genre-specific correlations of emotion developments. Extending the set of tracked
| | |
---|
589 | emotions to Plutchik’s classification, Kim et al. collect 2,000 books from the
| | |
---|
590 | Project Gutenberg that belong to five genres found in the Brown corpus[60], namely adventure, science fiction, mystery, humor and romance.
| | |
---|
591 | The authors extend the set of classification algorithms beyond random forests using
| | |
---|
592 | a
| | |
---|
593 | multi-layer perceptron and convolutional
| | |
---|
594 | neural networks, which achieves the best performance (0.59 F1-score). To
| | |
---|
595 | understand how uniform the emotion patterns in different genres are, the authors
| | |
---|
596 | introduce the notion of prototypicality, which is computed as
| | |
---|
597 | average of all emotion scores. Using this as a point of reference for each genre Kim
| | |
---|
598 | et al. use Spearman correlation to calculate the uniformity of emotions per genre.
| | |
---|
599 | The results of this analysis suggest that fear and anger are the most salient plot devices in fiction, while joy is only of mediocre stability, which is in line with
| | |
---|
600 | findings of Samothrakis and Fasli.
| | |
---|
601 |
| | |
---|
602 | The study by Henny-Krahmer[61] pursues
| | |
---|
603 | two goals: 1), to test whether different subgenres of Spanish American literature
| | |
---|
604 | differ in degree and kind of emotionality, and 2), whether emotions in the novels
| | |
---|
605 | are
| | |
---|
606 | expressed in direct speech of characters or in narrated text. To that end, they
| | |
---|
607 | conduct a subgenre classification experiment on a corpus of Spanish American novels
| | |
---|
608 | using sentiment values as features. To answer the first question, each novel is split
| | |
---|
609 | into five segments and for each sentence in the segment the emotion score (polarity
| | |
---|
610 | values + Plutchik’s basic emotions) is calculated using SentiWordNet[62] and NRC[63] dictionaries. The classifier achieves an average F1
| | |
---|
611 | of 0.52, which is higher than the most-frequent class baseline and, hence, provides
| | |
---|
612 | a
| | |
---|
613 | support for emotion-based features in subgenre classification. The analysis of
| | |
---|
614 | feature importance shows that the most salient features come from the sentiment
| | |
---|
615 | scores calculated from the characters’ direct speech and that novels with higher
| | |
---|
616 | values of positive speech are more likely to be sentimental novels.
| | |
---|
617 |
| | |
---|
618 | There are some limitations to the studies presented in this section. On the one hand,
| | |
---|
619 | it is questionable how reliable coarse emotion scoring is that
| | |
---|
620 | takes into account only presence or absence of words found in specialized
| | |
---|
621 | dictionaries and overlooks negations and modifiers that can either negate an emotion
| | |
---|
622 | word or increase/decrease its intensity. On the other hand, a limited view of the
| | |
---|
623 | emotional content as a sum of emotion bearing words reserves no room for qualitative
| | |
---|
624 | interpretation of the texts – it is not clear how one can distinguish between emotion
| | |
---|
625 | words used by the author to express their sentiment, between words used to describe
| | |
---|
626 | characters’ feelings, and emotion words that characters use to address or describe
| | |
---|
627 | other characters in a story.
| | |
---|
628 |
| | |
---|
629 |
| | |
---|
630 |
| | |
---|
631 |
| | |
---|
632 | 4.3 Temporal Change of Sentiment
| | |
---|
633 |
| | |
---|
634 | The papers that we have reviewed so far approach the problem of sentiment and emotion
| | |
---|
635 | analysis as a classification task. However, applications of sentiment analysis are
| | |
---|
636 | not only limited to classification. In other fields, for example computational social
| | |
---|
637 | sciences, sentiment analysis can be used for analyzing political preferences of the
| | |
---|
638 | electorate or for mining opinions about different products or topics. Similarly,
| | |
---|
639 | several digital humanities studies incorporate sentiment analysis methods in a task
| | |
---|
640 | of mining sentiments and emotions of people who lived in the past. The goal of these
| | |
---|
641 | studies is not only to recognize sentiments, but also to understand how they were
| | |
---|
642 | formed.
| | |
---|
643 |
| | |
---|
644 |
| | |
---|
645 | 4.3.1 Topography of emotions
| | |
---|
646 |
| | |
---|
647 | Heuser et al.[64] start with a premise
| | |
---|
648 | that emotions occur at a specific moment in time and space, thus making it possible
| | |
---|
649 | to link emotions to specific geographical locations. Consequently, having such
| | |
---|
650 | information at hand, one can understand which emotions are hidden behind certain
| | |
---|
651 | landmarks. As a proof-of-concept, Heuser et al. build an interactive map,
| | |
---|
652 | Mapping emotions in Victorian London[65], where each location is tagged with emotion
| | |
---|
653 | labels. To construct a corpus for their analysis, Heuser et al. collect a large
| | |
---|
654 | corpus of English books from the eighteenth and nineteenth century and extract 383
| | |
---|
655 | geographical locations of London that have at least ten mentions each. The resulting
| | |
---|
656 | corpus includes 15,000 passages, each of which has a toponym in the middle and 100
| | |
---|
657 | words directly preceding and following the location mention. The data is then given
| | |
---|
658 | to annotators who are asked to define whether each of the passages expressed happiness or fear, or neutrality. The same data is also analyzed by a custom sentiment analysis
| | |
---|
659 | program that would assign each passage one of these emotion categories.
| | |
---|
660 |
| | |
---|
661 | Some striking observations are made with regard to the data analysis. First, there
| | |
---|
662 | is
| | |
---|
663 | a clear discrepancy between fiction and reality – while toponyms from the West End
| | |
---|
664 | with Westminster and the City are over-represented in the books, the same does not
| | |
---|
665 | hold true for the East End with Tower Hamlets, Southwark, and Hackney. Hence, there
| | |
---|
666 | is less information about emotions pertaining to these particular London locations.
| | |
---|
667 | Another striking detail is that the resulting map is dominated by the neutral
| | |
---|
668 | emotion. Heuser et al. argue that this has nothing to do with the absence of emotions
| | |
---|
669 | but rather stems from the fact that emotions tend to be silenced in public domain,
| | |
---|
670 | which influenced the annotators decision.
| | |
---|
671 |
| | |
---|
672 | The space and time context are also used by Bruggman and Fabrikant[66] who model sentiments of Swiss
| | |
---|
673 | historians towards places in Switzerland in different historical periods. As the
| | |
---|
674 | authors note, it is unlikely that a historian will directly express attitudes towards
| | |
---|
675 | certain toponyms, but it is very likely that words they use to describe those can
| | |
---|
676 | bear some negative connotation (e.g. cholera, death). Correspondingly, such places
| | |
---|
677 | should be identified as bearing negative sentiment by a sentiment analysis tool.
| | |
---|
678 | Additionally, they study the changes of sentiment towards a particular place over
| | |
---|
679 | time. Using the General Inquirer (GI) lexicon[67] to identify
| | |
---|
680 | positive and negative terms in the document, they assign each document a sentiment
| | |
---|
681 | score by summing up the weights of negative and positive words and normalizing them
| | |
---|
682 | by the document length. The authors conclude that the results of their analysis look
| | |
---|
683 | promising, especially regarding negatively scored articles. However, the authors find
| | |
---|
684 | difficulties in interpreting positively ranked documents, which may be due to the
| | |
---|
685 | fact that negative information is more salient.
| | |
---|
686 |
| | |
---|
687 |
| | |
---|
688 |
| | |
---|
689 | 4.3.2 Tracking sentiment
| | |
---|
690 |
| | |
---|
691 | Other papers in this category link sentiment and emotion to certain groups, rather
| | |
---|
692 | than geographical locations. The goal of these studies is to understand how sentiment
| | |
---|
693 | within and towards these groups was formed.
| | |
---|
694 |
| | |
---|
695 | Taboada et al.[68]
| | |
---|
696 | aim at tracking the literary reputation of six authors writing in the first half of
| | |
---|
697 | the twentieth century. The research questions raised in the project are how the
| | |
---|
698 | reputation is made or lost, and how to find correlation between what is written about
| | |
---|
699 | the author and their work to the author’s reputation and subsequent canonicity. To
| | |
---|
700 | that end, the project’s goal is to examine critical reviews of six authors’ writing
| | |
---|
701 | and to map information contained in texts critical to the author’s reputation. The
| | |
---|
702 | material they work with includes not only reviews, but also press notes, press
| | |
---|
703 | articles, and letters to editors (including from the authors themselves). For the
| | |
---|
704 | pilot project with Galsworthy and Lawrence they collected and scanned 330 documents
| | |
---|
705 | (480,000 words). The documents are tagged for the parts of speech and relevant words
| | |
---|
706 | (positive and negative) are extracted using custom-made sentiment dictionaries. The
| | |
---|
707 | sentiment orientation of rhetorically important parts of the texts is then measured.
| | |
---|
708 |
| | |
---|
709 |
| | |
---|
710 | Chen et al.[69] aim to understand personal
| | |
---|
711 | narratives of Korean comfort women who had been forced into
| | |
---|
712 | sexual slavery by Japanese military during World War II. Adapting the WordNet-Affect lexicon,[70] Chen et
| | |
---|
713 | al. build their own emotion dictionary to spot emotional keywords in women’s stories
| | |
---|
714 | and map the sentences to emotion categories. By adding variables of time and space,
| | |
---|
715 | Chen et al. provide a unified framework of collective remembering of this historical
| | |
---|
716 | event as witnessed by the victims.
| | |
---|
717 |
| | |
---|
718 | Finally, an interesting project to follow is the Oceanic Exchanges[71] project that started in late 2017. One goal of the project is
| | |
---|
719 | to trace information exchange in nineteenth-century newspapers and journals using
| | |
---|
720 | sentiment as one of the variables under analysis.
| | |
---|
721 |
| | |
---|
722 |
| | |
---|
723 |
| | |
---|
724 | 4.3.3 Sentiment recognition in historical texts
| | |
---|
725 |
| | |
---|
726 | Other papers put emphasis not so much on the sentiments expressed by writers but
| | |
---|
727 | instead focus on the particularities of historical language.
| | |
---|
728 |
| | |
---|
729 | Marchetti et al.[72] and Sprugnoli et
| | |
---|
730 | al.
| | |
---|
731 | [73] present the integration of
| | |
---|
732 | sentiment analysis in the ALCIDE (Analysis of Language and Content In a Digital Environment)
| | |
---|
733 | project[74]. The sentiment analysis module is
| | |
---|
734 | based on WordNet-Affect, SentiWordNet[75] and MultiWordNet.[76] Each
| | |
---|
735 | document is assigned a polarity score by summing up the words with prior polarity
| | |
---|
736 | and
| | |
---|
737 | dividing by the number of words in the document. A positive global score leads to
| | |
---|
738 | a
| | |
---|
739 | positive document polarity and a negative global score leads to a negative document
| | |
---|
740 | polarity. The overall conclusion of their work is that the assignment of a polarity
| | |
---|
741 | in the historical domain is a challenging task largely due to lack of agreement on
| | |
---|
742 | polarity of historical sources between human annotators.
| | |
---|
743 |
| | |
---|
744 | Challenged by the problem of applicability of existing emotion lexicons to historical
| | |
---|
745 | texts, Buechel et al.[77] propose a new
| | |
---|
746 | method of constructing affective lexicons that would adapt well to German texts
| | |
---|
747 | written up to three centuries ago. In their study, Buechel et al. use the
| | |
---|
748 | representation of affect based on the Valence-Arousal-Dominance
| | |
---|
749 | model (an adaptation of Russel’s circumplex model, see Section 2.3).
| | |
---|
750 | Presumably, such a representation provides a finer-grained insight into the literary
| | |
---|
751 | text,[78] which is more expressive
| | |
---|
752 | than discrete categories, as it quantifies the emotion along three different
| | |
---|
753 | dimensions. As a basis for the analysis, they collect German texts from the Deutsches Textarchiv[79] written
| | |
---|
754 | between 1690 and 1899. The corpus is split into seven slices, each spanning 30 years.
| | |
---|
755 | For each slice they compute word similarities and obtain seven distinct emotion
| | |
---|
756 | lexicons, each corresponding to specific time period. This allows for, the authors
| | |
---|
757 | argue, the tracing of the shift in emotion association of words over time.
| | |
---|
758 |
| | |
---|
759 | Finally, Leemans et al.[80] aim to
| | |
---|
760 | trace historical changes in emotion expressions and to develop methods to trace these
| | |
---|
761 | changes in a corpus of 29 Dutch language theatre plays written between 1600 and 1800.
| | |
---|
762 | Expanding the Dutch version of Linguistic Inquiry and Word Count (LIWC) dictionary[81] with
| | |
---|
763 | historical terms, the authors are able to increase the recall of emotion recognition
| | |
---|
764 | with a dictionary. In addition, they develop a fine-grained vocabulary mapping body
| | |
---|
765 | terms to emotions, and show that a combination of LIWC and their lexicon lead to
| | |
---|
766 | improvement in the emotion recognition.
| | |
---|
767 |
| | |
---|
768 |
| | |
---|
769 |
| | |
---|
770 |
| | |
---|
771 | 4.4 Character Network Analysis and Relationship Extraction
| | |
---|
772 |
| | |
---|
773 | The papers reviewed above address sentiment analysis of literary texts mainly on a
| | |
---|
774 | document level. This abstraction is warranted if the goal is to get an insight into
| | |
---|
775 | the distribution of emotions in a corpus of books. However, emotions depicted in
| | |
---|
776 | books do not exist in isolation but are associated with characters who are at the
| | |
---|
777 | core of any literary narrative.[82] This leads us to ask what sentiment and emotion analysis can tell us
| | |
---|
778 | about the characters. How emotional are they? And what role do emotions play in their
| | |
---|
779 | interaction?
| | |
---|
780 |
| | |
---|
781 | Character relationships have been analyzed in computational linguistics from a graph
| | |
---|
782 | theoretic perspective, particularly using social network analysis.[83] Fewer works,
| | |
---|
783 | however, address the problem of modeling character relationships in terms of
| | |
---|
784 | sentiment. Below we provide an overview of several papers that propose the
| | |
---|
785 | methodology for extracting this information.
| | |
---|
786 |
| | |
---|
787 |
| | |
---|
788 | 4.4.1 Sentiment dynamics between characters
| | |
---|
789 |
| | |
---|
790 | Several studies present automatic methods for analyzing sentiment dynamics between
| | |
---|
791 | plays’ characters. The goal of the study by Nalisnick and Baird[84] is to track the emotional trajectories of
| | |
---|
792 | interpersonal relationships. The structured format of a dialog allows them to
| | |
---|
793 | identify who is speaking to whom, which makes it possible to mine
| | |
---|
794 | character-to-character sentiment by summing the valence values of words that appear
| | |
---|
795 | in the continuous direct speech and are found in the lexicon[85]
| | |
---|
796 | of affective norms. The extension[86] of the previous research from the same authors
| | |
---|
797 | introduces the concept of a sentiment network, a dynamic social network of
| | |
---|
798 | characters. Changing polarities between characters are modeled as edge weights in
| | |
---|
799 | the
| | |
---|
800 | network. Motivated by the desire to explain such networks in terms of a general
| | |
---|
801 | sociological model, Nalisnick and Baird test whether Shakespeare’s plays obey the
| | |
---|
802 | Structural Balance Theory by Marvel et al.[87] that postulates that a friend of a
| | |
---|
803 | friend is also your friend. Using the procedure proposed by Marvel et al. on their
| | |
---|
804 | Shakespearean sentiment networks, Nalisnick and Baird test whether they can predict
| | |
---|
805 | how a play’s characters will split into factions using only information about the
| | |
---|
806 | state of the sentiment network after Act II. The results of their analysis are varied
| | |
---|
807 | and do not provide adequate support for the Structural Balance Theory as a benchmark
| | |
---|
808 | for network analysis in Shakespeare’s plays. One reason for that, as the authors
| | |
---|
809 | state, is inadequacy of their shallow sentiment analysis methods that cannot detect
| | |
---|
810 | such elements of speech as irony and deceit that play a pivotal role in many literary
| | |
---|
811 | works.
| | |
---|
812 |
| | |
---|
813 |
| | |
---|
814 |
| | |
---|
815 | 4.4.2 Character analysis and character relationships
| | |
---|
816 |
| | |
---|
817 | Elsner[88] aims at answering the
| | |
---|
818 | question of how to represent a plot structure for summarization and generation tools.
| | |
---|
819 | To that end, Elsner presents a kernel for comparing novelistic
| | |
---|
820 | plots at the level of character interactions and their relationships. Using sentiment
| | |
---|
821 | as one of the characteristics of a character, Elsner demonstrates that the kernel
| | |
---|
822 | approach leads to meaningful plot representation that can be used for a higher-level
| | |
---|
823 | processing.
| | |
---|
824 |
| | |
---|
825 | Kim and Klinger[89] aim at understanding
| | |
---|
826 | the causes of emotions experienced by literary characters. To that end, they
| | |
---|
827 | contribute the REMAN
| | |
---|
828 | corpus[90] of literary texts with annotations of emotions,
| | |
---|
829 | experiencers, causes and targets of the emotions. The goal of the project is to
| | |
---|
830 | enable the automatic extraction of emotions and causes of emotions experienced by
| | |
---|
831 | the
| | |
---|
832 | characters. The authors suggest that the results of coarse-grained emotion
| | |
---|
833 | classification in literary text are not readily interpretable as they do not tell
| | |
---|
834 | much about who the experiencer of the emotion is. Indeed, if a text mentions two
| | |
---|
835 | characters, one of whom is angry and another one who is scared because of that, text classification models will only
| | |
---|
836 | tell us that the text is about anger and fear. Hence, a finer-grained approach towards character relationship
| | |
---|
837 | extraction is warranted. Kim and Klinger conduct experiments on the annotated dataset
| | |
---|
838 | showing that the fine-grained approach to emotion prediction with long short-term
| | |
---|
839 | memory networks outperforms bag-of-words models (an increase
| | |
---|
840 | in F1 by 12 pp). At the same time, the results of their experiments suggest that
| | |
---|
841 | joint prediction of emotions and experiencers can be more beneficial than studying
| | |
---|
842 | these categories separately.
| | |
---|
843 |
| | |
---|
844 | Barth et al.[91] develop the character
| | |
---|
845 | relation analysis tool rCAT with the goal of visualization and
| | |
---|
846 | analysis of character networks in a literary text. The tool implements a distance
| | |
---|
847 | parameter (based on token space) for finding pairs of interacting characters. In
| | |
---|
848 | addition to the general context words that characterize each pair of characters, the
| | |
---|
849 | tool provides an emotion filter to restrict character relationship analysis to
| | |
---|
850 | emotions only.
| | |
---|
851 |
| | |
---|
852 | A tool presented by Jhavar and Mirza[92] provides a similar functionality: given an input of two character
| | |
---|
853 | names from the Harry Potter series, the EMoFiel[93] tool identifies the emotion flow between a
| | |
---|
854 | given directed pair of story characters. These emotions are identified using
| | |
---|
855 | categorical[94] and continuous[95] emotion models.
| | |
---|
856 |
| | |
---|
857 | Egloff et al.[96] present an ongoing
| | |
---|
858 | work on the Ontology of Literary Characters (OLC) that allows
| | |
---|
859 | us to capture and infer characters’ psychological traits from their linguistic
| | |
---|
860 | descriptions. The OLC incorporates the Ontology of Emotion[97] that is based on both Plutchik’s and
| | |
---|
861 | Hourglass’s[98] models of emotions.
| | |
---|
862 | The ontology encodes 32 emotion concepts. Based on their natural language
| | |
---|
863 | description, characters are attributed to a psychological profile along the classes
| | |
---|
864 | of Openness to experience, Conscientiousness, Extraversion, Agreeableness, and Neuroticism. The ontology links
| | |
---|
865 | each of these profiles to one or more archetypal categories of hero, anti-hero, and villain.
| | |
---|
866 | Egloff et al. argue that, by using the semantic connections of the OLC, it is
| | |
---|
867 | possible to infer the characters’ psychological profiles and the role they play in
| | |
---|
868 | the plot.
| | |
---|
869 |
| | |
---|
870 | Kim and Klinger[99] propose a new task
| | |
---|
871 | of emotion relationship classification between fictional characters. They argue that
| | |
---|
872 | joining character network analysis with sentiment and emotion analysis may contribute
| | |
---|
873 | to a computational understanding of narrative structures, as characters are at the
| | |
---|
874 | center of any plot development. Building a corpus of 19 fan fiction short stories
| | |
---|
875 | and
| | |
---|
876 | annotating it with emotions, Kim and Klinger propose several models to classify
| | |
---|
877 | emotion relations of characters. They show that a deep learning architecture with
| | |
---|
878 | character position indicators is the best for the task of predicting both directed
| | |
---|
879 | and undirected emotion relations in the associated social network graph. As an
| | |
---|
880 | extension to this study, Kim and Klinger[100] explore how emotions are expressed between characters in the same
| | |
---|
881 | corpus via various non-verbal communication channels.[101] They find
| | |
---|
882 | that facial expressions are predominantly associated with joy
| | |
---|
883 | while gestures and body postures are more likely to occur with trust.
| | |
---|
884 |
| | |
---|
885 | Finally, a small body of work focuses on mathematical modeling of character
| | |
---|
886 | relationships. Rinaldi et al.[102]
| | |
---|
887 | contribute a model that describes the love story between the Beauty and the Beast
| | |
---|
888 | through ordinary differential equations. Zhuravlev et al.[103] introduce a distance function to model the
| | |
---|
889 | relationship between the protagonist and other characters in two masochistic short
| | |
---|
890 | novels by Ivan Turgenev and Sacher-Masoch. Borrowing some instruments from the
| | |
---|
891 | literary criticism and using ordinary differential equations, Zhuravlev et al. are
| | |
---|
892 | able to reproduce the temporal and spatial dynamics of the love plot in the two
| | |
---|
893 | novellas more precisely than it had been done in previous research. Jafari et
| | |
---|
894 | al.[104] present a dynamic model
| | |
---|
895 | describing the development of character relationships based on differential
| | |
---|
896 | equations. The proposed model is enriched with complex variables that can represent
| | |
---|
897 | complex emotions such as coexisting love and hate.
| | |
---|
898 |
| | |
---|
899 |
| | |
---|
900 |
| | |
---|
901 |
| | |
---|
902 | 4.5 Other Types of Emotion Analysis
| | |
---|
903 |
| | |
---|
904 | We have seen that sentiment analysis as applied to literature can be used for a
| | |
---|
905 | number of downstream tasks, such as classification of texts based on the emotions
| | |
---|
906 | they convey, genre classification based on emotions, and sentiment analysis in the
| | |
---|
907 | historical domain. However, the application of sentiment analysis is not limited to
| | |
---|
908 | these tasks. In this concluding part of the survey, we review some papers that do
| | |
---|
909 | not
| | |
---|
910 | formulate their approach to sentiment analysis as a downstream task. Often, the goal
| | |
---|
911 | of these works is to understand how sentiments and emotions are represented in
| | |
---|
912 | literary texts in general, and how sentiment or emotion content varies across
| | |
---|
913 | specific documents or a collection of them with time, where time can be either
| | |
---|
914 | relative to the text in question (from beginning to end) or to the historical changes
| | |
---|
915 | in language (from past to present). Such information is valuable for gaining a deeper
| | |
---|
916 | insight into how sentiments and emotions change over time, allowing us to bring
| | |
---|
917 | forward new theories or shed more light onto existing literary or sociological
| | |
---|
918 | theories.
| | |
---|
919 |
| | |
---|
920 |
| | |
---|
921 | 4.5.1 Emotion flow analysis and visualization
| | |
---|
922 |
| | |
---|
923 | A set of authors aimed to visualize the change of emotion content through texts or
| | |
---|
924 | across time. One of the earliest works in this direction is a paper by Anderson and
| | |
---|
925 | McMaster[105] that starts from
| | |
---|
926 | the premise that reading enjoyment stems from the affective tones of a text. These
| | |
---|
927 | affective tones create a conflict that can rise to a climax through a series of
| | |
---|
928 | crises, which is necessary for a work of fiction to be attractive to the reader.
| | |
---|
929 | Using a list of 1,000 of the most common English words annotated with valence,
| | |
---|
930 | arousal, and dominance ratings,[106] they
| | |
---|
931 | calculate the conflict score by taking the mean of the ratings for each word in a
| | |
---|
932 | text passage. The more negative the score is, the higher the conflict is, and vice
| | |
---|
933 | versa. Additionally, they plot conflict scores for each consecutive 100 words of a
| | |
---|
934 | test story and provide qualitative analysis of the peaks. They argue that a reader
| | |
---|
935 | who has access to the text would be able to find correlation between events in the
| | |
---|
936 | story and peaks on the graph. However, the authors still stress that such
| | |
---|
937 | interpretation remains dependent upon the judgement of the reader. Further, other
| | |
---|
938 | contributions by the authors are based on the same premises.[107]
| | |
---|
939 | Alm and Sproat[108] present the results of
| | |
---|
940 | the emotion annotation task of 22 tales by the Grimm brothers and evaluate patterns
| | |
---|
941 | of emotional story development. They split emotions into positive and negative categories and divide each
| | |
---|
942 | story into five parts from which aggregate frequency counts of combined emotion
| | |
---|
943 | categories are computed. The resulting numbers are plotted on a graph that shows a
| | |
---|
944 | wave-shaped pattern. From this graph, Alm and Sproat argue, one can see that the
| | |
---|
945 | first part of the fairy tales is the least emotional, which is probably due to scene
| | |
---|
946 | setting, while the last part shows an increase in positive emotions, which may
| | |
---|
947 | signify the happy ending.
| | |
---|
948 |
| | |
---|
949 | Two other studies by Mohammad[109] focus on differences in emotion word density as well as emotional
| | |
---|
950 | trajectories between books of different genres. Emotion word density is defined as
| | |
---|
951 | a
| | |
---|
952 | number of times a reader will encounter an emotion word on reading every X words. In addition, each text is assigned several emotion
| | |
---|
953 | scores for each emotion that are calculated as a ratio of words associated with one
| | |
---|
954 | emotion to the total number of emotion words occurring in a text. Both metrics use
| | |
---|
955 | the NRC Affective Lexicon to find occurrences of emotion
| | |
---|
956 | words. They find that fairy tales have significantly higher anticipation, disgust, joy and
| | |
---|
957 | surprise word densities, but lower trust word densities when compared to novels.
| | |
---|
958 |
| | |
---|
959 | A work by Klinger et al.[110] is a case
| | |
---|
960 | study in an automatic emotion analysis of Kafka’s Amerika and Das Schloss. The goal of the work is to analyze the development of emotions in both texts
| | |
---|
961 | as well as to provide a character-oriented emotion analysis that would reveal
| | |
---|
962 | specific character traits in both texts. To that end, Klinger et al. develop German
| | |
---|
963 | dictionaries of words associated with Ekman’s fundamental emotions plus contempt and
| | |
---|
964 | apply them to both texts in question to automatically detect emotion words. The
| | |
---|
965 | results of their analysis for Das Schloss show a striking increase of surprise towards the end
| | |
---|
966 | and a peak of fear shortly after start of chapter 3. In the
| | |
---|
967 | case of Amerika, the analysis shows that there is a decrease in enjoyment after a peak in chapter 4.
| | |
---|
968 |
| | |
---|
969 | Yet another work that tracks the flow of emotions in a collection of texts is
| | |
---|
970 | presented by Kim et al.[111] The authors
| | |
---|
971 | hypothesize that literary genres can be linked to the development of emotions over
| | |
---|
972 | the course of text. To test this, they collect more than 2,000 books from five genres
| | |
---|
973 | (adventure, science fiction, mystery, humor and romance) from Project Gutenberg and identify prototypical emotion shapes for
| | |
---|
974 | each genre. Each novel in the corpus is split into five consecutive equally-sized
| | |
---|
975 | segments (following the five-act theory of dramatic acts).[112] All five genres show close correspondence with regard to sadness, anger, fear and disgust, i.e., a consistent increase of
| | |
---|
976 | these emotions from Act 1 to Act 5, which may correspond to an entertaining
| | |
---|
977 | narrative. Mystery and science fiction
| | |
---|
978 | books show increase in anger towards the end, and joy shows an inverse decreasing pattern from Act 1 to Act 2,
| | |
---|
979 | with the exception of humor.
| | |
---|
980 |
| | |
---|
981 | The work by Kakkonen and Galic Kakkonen[113] aims at supporting the literary analysis of Gothic texts at the sentiment level. The authors introduce a
| | |
---|
982 | system called SentiProfiler that generates visual
| | |
---|
983 | representations of affective content in such texts and outlines similarities and
| | |
---|
984 | differences between them, however, without considering the temporal dimension. The
| | |
---|
985 | SentiProfiler uses WordNet-Affect to
| | |
---|
986 | derive a list of emotion-bearing words that will be used for analysis. The resulting
| | |
---|
987 | sentiment profiles for the books are used to visualize the presence of sentiment in
| | |
---|
988 | a
| | |
---|
989 | particular document and to compare two different texts.
| | |
---|
990 |
| | |
---|
991 |
| | |
---|
992 |
| | |
---|
993 | 4.5.2 Miscellaneous
| | |
---|
994 |
| | |
---|
995 | In this section, we review studies that are different in goals and research questions
| | |
---|
996 | from the papers presented in previous sections and do not constitute a category on
| | |
---|
997 | their own.
| | |
---|
998 |
| | |
---|
999 | Koolen[114] claims that there is a bias among
| | |
---|
1000 | readers that put works by female authors on par with »women’s books«, which, as
| | |
---|
1001 | stated by the author, tend to be perceived as of lower literary quality. She
| | |
---|
1002 | investigates how much »women’s books« (here, romantic novels
| | |
---|
1003 | written by women) differ from novels perceived as literary (female and male-authored
| | |
---|
1004 | literary fiction). The corpus used in the study is a collection of European and
| | |
---|
1005 | North-American novels translated into Dutch. Koolen uses a Dutch version of the Linguistic Inquiry and Word Count,[115] a dictionary that contains content and sentiment-related categories
| | |
---|
1006 | of words to count the number of words from different categories in each type of
| | |
---|
1007 | fiction. Her analysis shows that romantic novels contain more positive emotions and
| | |
---|
1008 | words pertaining to friendship than in literary fiction. However, female-authored
| | |
---|
1009 | literary novels and male-authored ones do not significantly differ on any category.
| | |
---|
1010 |
| | |
---|
1011 |
| | |
---|
1012 | Kraicer and Piper[116] explore the
| | |
---|
1013 | women’s place within contemporary fiction starting from the premise that there is
| | |
---|
1014 | a
| | |
---|
1015 | near ubiquitous underrepresentation and decentralization of women. As a part of their
| | |
---|
1016 | analysis, Kraicer and Piper use sentiment scores to look at social balance and
| | |
---|
1017 | »antagonism«, i.e., how different gender pairings influence positive and negative
| | |
---|
1018 | language surrounding the co-occurrence of characters (using the sentiment dictionary
| | |
---|
1019 | presented by Liu[117] to calculate a
| | |
---|
1020 | sentiment score for a character pair). Having analyzed a set of 26,450 characters
| | |
---|
1021 | from 1,333 novels published between 2001 and 2015, the authors find that sentiment
| | |
---|
1022 | scores give little indication that the character’s gender has an effect on the state
| | |
---|
1023 | of social balance.
| | |
---|
1024 |
| | |
---|
1025 | Morin and Acerbi[118] focus on
| | |
---|
1026 | larger-scale data spanning a hundred thousand of books. The goal of their study is
| | |
---|
1027 | to
| | |
---|
1028 | understand how emotionality of written texts changed throughout the centuries. Having
| | |
---|
1029 | collected 307,527 books written between 1900 and 2000 from the Google Books
| | |
---|
1030 | corpus[119] they collect, for each
| | |
---|
1031 | year, the total number of case-insensitive occurrences of emotion terms that are
| | |
---|
1032 | found under positive and negative taxonomies of LIWC
| | |
---|
1033 | dictionary.[120] The main findings
| | |
---|
1034 | of their research show that emotionality (both positive and
| | |
---|
1035 | negative emotions) declines with time, and this decline is
| | |
---|
1036 | driven by the decrease in usage of positive vocabulary. Morin and Acerbi remind us
| | |
---|
1037 | that the Romantic period was dominated by emotionality in
| | |
---|
1038 | writing, which could be the effect of a group of writers who wrote above the mean.
| | |
---|
1039 | If
| | |
---|
1040 | one assumes that each new writer tends to copy the emotional style of their
| | |
---|
1041 | predecessors, then writers at one point of time are disproportionally influenced by
| | |
---|
1042 | this group of above-the-mean writers. However, this trend does not last forever and,
| | |
---|
1043 | sooner or later, the trend reverts to the mean, as each writer reverts to a normal
| | |
---|
1044 | level of emotionality.
| | |
---|
1045 |
| | |
---|
1046 | An earlier work[121] written in
| | |
---|
1047 | collaboration with Acerbi provides a somewhat different
| | |
---|
1048 | approach and interpretation of the problem of the decline in positive vocabulary in
| | |
---|
1049 | English books of the twentieth century. Using the same dataset and lexical resources
| | |
---|
1050 | (plus WordNet-Affect) Bentley et al. find a strong correlation
| | |
---|
1051 | between expressed negative emotions and the U.S. economic misery
| | |
---|
1052 | index, which is especially strong for the books written during and after
| | |
---|
1053 | the World War I (1918), the Great Depression (1935), and the energy crisis (1975).
| | |
---|
1054 | However, in the present study,[122] the
| | |
---|
1055 | authors argue that the extent to which positive emotionality correlates with
| | |
---|
1056 | subjective well-being is a debatable issue. Morin and Acerbi provide more possible
| | |
---|
1057 | reasons for this effect as well as detailed statistical analysis of the data, so we
| | |
---|
1058 | refer the reader to the original paper for more information.
| | |
---|
1059 |
| | |
---|
1060 |
| | |
---|
1061 |
| | |
---|
1062 | Tab. 1: Summary of characteristics of methods used in the papers reviewed
| | |
---|
1063 | in this survey. Download as PDF. [Kim / Klinger 2019]
| | |
---|
1064 |
| | |
---|
1065 |
| | |
---|
1066 |
| | |
---|
1067 |
| | |
---|
1068 |
| | |
---|
1069 | 5 Discussion and Conclusion
| | |
---|
1070 |
| | |
---|
1071 | We have shown throughout this survey that there is a growing interest in sentiment
| | |
---|
1072 | and emotion analysis within digital humanities. Given the fact that DH have emerged
| | |
---|
1073 | into a thriving science within the past decade, it may safely be said that this
| | |
---|
1074 | direction of research is relatively new. At the same time, the research in sentiment
| | |
---|
1075 | analysis started in computational linguistic more than two decades ago and is
| | |
---|
1076 | nowadays an established field that has dedicated workshops and tracks in the main
| | |
---|
1077 | computational linguistics conferences. Moreover, a recent meta-study by Mäntylä et
| | |
---|
1078 | al.[123] shows that the number of
| | |
---|
1079 | papers in sentiment analysis is rapidly increasing each year. Indeed, the topic has
| | |
---|
1080 | not yet outrun itself and we should not expect to see it vanishing within the next
| | |
---|
1081 | decade or two, provided that no significant paradigm shift in the computational
| | |
---|
1082 | sciences takes place. One may wonder whether the same applies to sentiment analysis
| | |
---|
1083 | in digital humanities scholarship. Will the interest in the topic grow continuously
| | |
---|
1084 | or will it rally to the peak and vanish in a few years?
| | |
---|
1085 |
| | |
---|
1086 | There is no decisive answer. The popularity of sentiment analysis may have reached
| | |
---|
1087 | a
| | |
---|
1088 | peak but is far from fading. Application-wise, not a lot has changed during the past
| | |
---|
1089 | years: researchers are still interested in predicting sentiment and emotion from text
| | |
---|
1090 | for different purposes. If anything has changed, it is methodology. Early research
| | |
---|
1091 | in
| | |
---|
1092 | sentiment analysis relied on word polarity and specific dictionaries. Modern
| | |
---|
1093 | state-of-the-art approaches rely on word embeddings and deep learning architectures.
| | |
---|
1094 | Having started with simple polarity detection, contemporary sentiment analysis has
| | |
---|
1095 | advanced to a more nuanced analysis of sentiments and emotions.
| | |
---|
1096 |
| | |
---|
1097 | The situation is somewhat different in digital humanities research. Most of the works
| | |
---|
1098 | rely on affective lexicons and word counts, a technique for detecting emotions in
| | |
---|
1099 | literary text first used by Anderson and McMaster in 1982.[124] Even the most recent works base the
| | |
---|
1100 | interpretation of the results on the use of dictionaries and counts of
| | |
---|
1101 | emotion-bearing words in a text, passage, or sentence. In fact, around 70% of the
| | |
---|
1102 | papers we discussed in Section 4 substantially rely on the use of various lexical
| | |
---|
1103 | resources for detecting emotions (see Table 1 for a summary of methods used in the
| | |
---|
1104 | reviewed papers). We have discussed some limitations of this approach in Section 4.2.
| | |
---|
1105 | Let us reiterate its weakness with the following small example. Consider the sentence
| | |
---|
1106 | ›Jack was afraid of John because John held a knife in his hand‹. Assuming a
| | |
---|
1107 | dictionary of emotion-bearing words is used, the sentence can be categorized as
| | |
---|
1108 | expressing fear, because of the two strong fear markers, afraid and knife. Indeed, the sentence
| | |
---|
1109 | does express fear. But does it do it equally for Jack and
| | |
---|
1110 | John? The answer is no: Jack is the one who is afraid and John holding a knife is
| | |
---|
1111 | the
| | |
---|
1112 | reason for Jack being afraid. Let us assume that a researcher is interested in the
| | |
---|
1113 | emotion analysis of a book that contains thousands of sentences expressing emotions
| | |
---|
1114 | in different ways: some sentences describe characters who feel emotions just as in
| | |
---|
1115 | the sentence above, some are narrator’s digressions filled with emotions, some
| | |
---|
1116 | contain emotion-bearing words (knife, baby) but do not in fact express the same emotion in any given context. No
| | |
---|
1117 | doubt, a dictionary and count-based approach will be helpful in understanding the
| | |
---|
1118 | distribution of the emotion lexicon throughout the story. But is it enough for the
| | |
---|
1119 | interpretation? Can hermeneutics, in its traditional form, make use of such
| | |
---|
1120 | knowledge? Barely. In fact, some of the works that we reviewed pinpoint that the
| | |
---|
1121 | surface affective value of the words does not always align with their more nuanced
| | |
---|
1122 | affective meaning and that sentiment analysis tools make mistakes when classifying
| | |
---|
1123 | a
| | |
---|
1124 | text as emotional or not.[125] If so, how reliable
| | |
---|
1125 | is the interpretation? In other words, what kind of interpretation should we expect
| | |
---|
1126 | from the sentiment and emotion analysis research in the DH community?
| | |
---|
1127 |
| | |
---|
1128 | We do not have a ready answer to that question. At the one extreme, there is
| | |
---|
1129 | traditional hermeneutics, the examples of which are presented in a Section 3. At the
| | |
---|
1130 | other extreme, there is interpretation in the form of ›Author A writes with more
| | |
---|
1131 | emotion than author B because the numbers say so‹. We do, however, suggest that a
| | |
---|
1132 | balance should be made somewhere between these two extremes. Even as simple as it
| | |
---|
1133 | is,
| | |
---|
1134 | the approach of detecting sentiment and emotion-related words can be used to deliver
| | |
---|
1135 | a high-quality interpretation such as in Heuser et al.[126] or Morin and Acerbi.[127] However, we note again that there are still limits posed by the
| | |
---|
1136 | simplicity of this approach.
| | |
---|
1137 |
| | |
---|
1138 | This leads us to an outline of the reality of sentiment analysis research in digital
| | |
---|
1139 | humanities: the methods of sentiment analysis used by some of the DH scholars
| | |
---|
1140 | nowadays have gone or are almost extinct among computational linguists. This in turn
| | |
---|
1141 | affects the quality of the interpretation.
| | |
---|
1142 |
| | |
---|
1143 | However, we admit that this criticism may be unfair. In fact, there is a possible
| | |
---|
1144 | reason why DH researchers have taken this approach to sentiment analysis. Digital
| | |
---|
1145 | humanities are still being formed as an independent discipline and it is easier to
| | |
---|
1146 | form something new in a step-by-step fashion. Resorting to a metaphor from the
| | |
---|
1147 | construction world, one should first learn how to stack single bricks to build a wall
| | |
---|
1148 | rather than starting from the design of a communications system. It is necessary to
| | |
---|
1149 | make sure that appropriate tools and methods are chosen instead of using what proved
| | |
---|
1150 | to be successful in other domains without reflection. It is true that much digital
| | |
---|
1151 | humanities research (especially dealing with text) uses the methods of text analysis
| | |
---|
1152 | that were in fashion in computational linguistic twenty years ago. One may argue that
| | |
---|
1153 | new research in digital humanities should start with the state-of-the-art methods. Indeed, some arguments that methodology is at
| | |
---|
1154 | the root of the interpretation have already been made.[128] So, if there is anything that digital humanities can learn from
| | |
---|
1155 | computational linguistics, it is that methodology cannot stall. What really matters
| | |
---|
1156 | for digital humanities is interpretation, and if methodology is not going forward,
| | |
---|
1157 | the interpretation is not either.
| | |
---|
1158 |
| | |
---|
1159 |
| | |
---|
1160 |
| | |
---|
1161 | Acknowledgements
| | |
---|
1162 |
| | |
---|
1163 |
| | |
---|
1164 | We thank Laura Ana Maria Bostan, Sebastian Padó, and Enrica Troiano
| | |
---|
1165 | for fruitful discussions and the ZfDG team for their help in preparation of this
| | |
---|
1166 | article. This research has been conducted within the CRETA project which is funded by the German Ministry for Education and
| | |
---|
1167 | Research (BMBF) and partially funded by the German Research Council (DFG), projects
| | |
---|
1168 | SEAT (Structured Multi-Domain Emotion Analysis from Text, KL 2869/1-1).
| | |
---|
1169 |
| | |
---|
1170 |
| | |
---|
1171 |
| | |
---|
1172 |
| | |
---|
1173 |
| | |
---|
1174 | Footnotes
| | |
---|
1175 |
| | |
---|
1176 |
| | |
---|
1177 | [1]
| | |
---|
1178 |
| | |
---|
1179 | Liu 2015, p.2.
| | |
---|
1180 |
| | |
---|
1181 |
| | |
---|
1182 | [2]
| | |
---|
1183 |
| | |
---|
1184 | Soleymani et al. 2017.
| | |
---|
1185 |
| | |
---|
1186 |
| | |
---|
1187 | [3]
| | |
---|
1188 |
| | |
---|
1189 | Scherer 2005, p. 695.
| | |
---|
1190 |
| | |
---|
1191 |
| | |
---|
1192 | [4]
| | |
---|
1193 |
| | |
---|
1194 | Scarantino 2016, p. 36.
| | |
---|
1195 |
| | |
---|
1196 |
| | |
---|
1197 | [5]
| | |
---|
1198 |
| | |
---|
1199 | Mayer et al. 2008, p. 510.
| | |
---|
1200 |
| | |
---|
1201 |
| | |
---|
1202 | [6]
| | |
---|
1203 |
| | |
---|
1204 | Da 2019, p. 602.
| | |
---|
1205 |
| | |
---|
1206 |
| | |
---|
1207 | [7]
| | |
---|
1208 |
| | |
---|
1209 | Moretti 2005.
| | |
---|
1210 |
| | |
---|
1211 |
| | |
---|
1212 | [8]
| | |
---|
1213 |
| | |
---|
1214 | Hoover et al. 2014.
| | |
---|
1215 |
| | |
---|
1216 |
| | |
---|
1217 | [9]
| | |
---|
1218 |
| | |
---|
1219 | Schwarz 2000, p. 433.
| | |
---|
1220 |
| | |
---|
1221 |
| | |
---|
1222 | [10]
| | |
---|
1223 |
| | |
---|
1224 | Johnson-Laird / Oatley 2016,
| | |
---|
1225 | passim; Djikic et al. 2009, passim.
| | |
---|
1226 |
| | |
---|
1227 |
| | |
---|
1228 | [11]
| | |
---|
1229 |
| | |
---|
1230 | Robinson 2005;
| | |
---|
1231 | Hogan 2010;
| | |
---|
1232 | Hogan 2011;
| | |
---|
1233 | Bal / Veltkamp 2013;
| | |
---|
1234 | Djikic et al. 2013;
| | |
---|
1235 | Johnson 2012;
| | |
---|
1236 | Samur et al. 2018.
| | |
---|
1237 |
| | |
---|
1238 | [12]
| | |
---|
1239 |
| | |
---|
1240 | Zillmann et al. 1980;
| | |
---|
1241 | Ross 1999;
| | |
---|
1242 | Bryant / Zillmann 1984;
| | |
---|
1243 | Oliver 2008;
| | |
---|
1244 | Mar et al.
| | |
---|
1245 | 2011.
| | |
---|
1246 |
| | |
---|
1247 | [13]
| | |
---|
1248 |
| | |
---|
1249 | Plato 1969
| | |
---|
1250 | , passim.
| | |
---|
1251 |
| | |
---|
1252 |
| | |
---|
1253 | [14]
| | |
---|
1254 |
| | |
---|
1255 | Aristotle 1996, passim.
| | |
---|
1256 |
| | |
---|
1257 |
| | |
---|
1258 | [15]
| | |
---|
1259 |
| | |
---|
1260 | De Sousa / Scarantino 2018.
| | |
---|
1261 |
| | |
---|
1262 |
| | |
---|
1263 | [16]
| | |
---|
1264 |
| | |
---|
1265 | Tolstoy 1962, passim.
| | |
---|
1266 |
| | |
---|
1267 |
| | |
---|
1268 | [17]
| | |
---|
1269 |
| | |
---|
1270 | Anderson / McMaster 1986, p. 3;
| | |
---|
1271 | Hogan 2010, p. 187; Piper /
| | |
---|
1272 | Jean So 2015.
| | |
---|
1273 |
| | |
---|
1274 |
| | |
---|
1275 | [18]
| | |
---|
1276 |
| | |
---|
1277 | Lanham 1989.
| | |
---|
1278 |
| | |
---|
1279 |
| | |
---|
1280 | [19]
| | |
---|
1281 |
| | |
---|
1282 | Berry 2012; Schreibman et al. 2015.
| | |
---|
1283 |
| | |
---|
1284 |
| | |
---|
1285 | [20]
| | |
---|
1286 |
| | |
---|
1287 | Vanhoutte 2013, p. 142;
| | |
---|
1288 | Jockers / Underwood
| | |
---|
1289 | 2016, pp. 292f.
| | |
---|
1290 |
| | |
---|
1291 |
| | |
---|
1292 | [21]
| | |
---|
1293 |
| | |
---|
1294 | Anderson /
| | |
---|
1295 | McMaster 1982.
| | |
---|
1296 |
| | |
---|
1297 |
| | |
---|
1298 | [22]
| | |
---|
1299 |
| | |
---|
1300 | Darwin 1872, passim.
| | |
---|
1301 |
| | |
---|
1302 |
| | |
---|
1303 | [23]
| | |
---|
1304 |
| | |
---|
1305 | Gendron / Feldman Barrett 2009.
| | |
---|
1306 |
| | |
---|
1307 |
| | |
---|
1308 | [24]
| | |
---|
1309 |
| | |
---|
1310 | Tomkins 1962, passim.
| | |
---|
1311 |
| | |
---|
1312 |
| | |
---|
1313 | [25]
| | |
---|
1314 |
| | |
---|
1315 | Ekman et al. 1969, pp. 86-88.
| | |
---|
1316 |
| | |
---|
1317 |
| | |
---|
1318 | [26]
| | |
---|
1319 |
| | |
---|
1320 | Ekman 1993, p. 386.
| | |
---|
1321 |
| | |
---|
1322 |
| | |
---|
1323 | [27]
| | |
---|
1324 |
| | |
---|
1325 | Feldman Barrett 1998, pp. 580f.
| | |
---|
1326 |
| | |
---|
1327 |
| | |
---|
1328 | [28]
| | |
---|
1329 |
| | |
---|
1330 | Russell 1994;
| | |
---|
1331 | Russell et al. 2003;
| | |
---|
1332 | Gendron et al. 2014;
| | |
---|
1333 | Feldman Barrett 2017.
| | |
---|
1334 |
| | |
---|
1335 |
| | |
---|
1336 | [29]
| | |
---|
1337 |
| | |
---|
1338 | Plutchik 1991, passim.
| | |
---|
1339 |
| | |
---|
1340 |
| | |
---|
1341 | [30]
| | |
---|
1342 |
| | |
---|
1343 | Cambria et al. 2012;
| | |
---|
1344 | Kim et al. 2012; Suttles / Ide 2013;
| | |
---|
1345 | Borth et al. 2013; Abdul-Mageed /
| | |
---|
1346 | Ungar 2017.
| | |
---|
1347 |
| | |
---|
1348 |
| | |
---|
1349 | [31]
| | |
---|
1350 |
| | |
---|
1351 | Smith / Schneider 2009, passim.
| | |
---|
1352 |
| | |
---|
1353 |
| | |
---|
1354 | [32]
| | |
---|
1355 |
| | |
---|
1356 | Richins 1997, p. 128.
| | |
---|
1357 |
| | |
---|
1358 |
| | |
---|
1359 | [33]
| | |
---|
1360 |
| | |
---|
1361 | Russell 1980.
| | |
---|
1362 |
| | |
---|
1363 |
| | |
---|
1364 | [34]
| | |
---|
1365 |
| | |
---|
1366 | Bradley / Lang 1994, p. 50.
| | |
---|
1367 |
| | |
---|
1368 |
| | |
---|
1369 | [35]
| | |
---|
1370 |
| | |
---|
1371 | Russell 2003, p. 154.
| | |
---|
1372 |
| | |
---|
1373 |
| | |
---|
1374 | [36]
| | |
---|
1375 |
| | |
---|
1376 | Larsen / Diener 1992, p. 25.
| | |
---|
1377 |
| | |
---|
1378 |
| | |
---|
1379 | [37]
| | |
---|
1380 |
| | |
---|
1381 | Russell / Feldman Barrett 1999, p. 807.
| | |
---|
1382 |
| | |
---|
1383 |
| | |
---|
1384 | [38]
| | |
---|
1385 |
| | |
---|
1386 | Sætre
| | |
---|
1387 | et al. 2014b, passim.
| | |
---|
1388 |
| | |
---|
1389 |
| | |
---|
1390 | [39]
| | |
---|
1391 |
| | |
---|
1392 | Van Meel 1995, passim.
| | |
---|
1393 |
| | |
---|
1394 |
| | |
---|
1395 | [40]
| | |
---|
1396 |
| | |
---|
1397 | Kuivalainen 2009, passim.
| | |
---|
1398 |
| | |
---|
1399 |
| | |
---|
1400 | [41]
| | |
---|
1401 |
| | |
---|
1402 | Barton 1996, passim.
| | |
---|
1403 |
| | |
---|
1404 |
| | |
---|
1405 | [42]
| | |
---|
1406 |
| | |
---|
1407 | Van Horn
| | |
---|
1408 | 1997, passim.
| | |
---|
1409 |
| | |
---|
1410 |
| | |
---|
1411 | [43]
| | |
---|
1412 |
| | |
---|
1413 | Johnson-Laird / Oatley 1989, passim.
| | |
---|
1414 |
| | |
---|
1415 |
| | |
---|
1416 | [44]
| | |
---|
1417 |
| | |
---|
1418 | Miller 2014, p. 92.
| | |
---|
1419 |
| | |
---|
1420 |
| | |
---|
1421 | [45]
| | |
---|
1422 |
| | |
---|
1423 | Sætre et al. 2014a, p. 91ff.
| | |
---|
1424 |
| | |
---|
1425 |
| | |
---|
1426 | [46]
| | |
---|
1427 |
| | |
---|
1428 | Miller 2014, p.
| | |
---|
1429 | 93.
| | |
---|
1430 |
| | |
---|
1431 |
| | |
---|
1432 | [47]
| | |
---|
1433 |
| | |
---|
1434 | Miller 2014, p. 115.
| | |
---|
1435 |
| | |
---|
1436 |
| | |
---|
1437 | [48]
| | |
---|
1438 |
| | |
---|
1439 | Liu 2015, p. 47.
| | |
---|
1440 |
| | |
---|
1441 |
| | |
---|
1442 | [49]
| | |
---|
1443 |
| | |
---|
1444 | Barros et al. 2013, passim.
| | |
---|
1445 |
| | |
---|
1446 |
| | |
---|
1447 | [50]
| | |
---|
1448 |
| | |
---|
1449 | Reed 2018, passim.
| | |
---|
1450 |
| | |
---|
1451 |
| | |
---|
1452 | [51]
| | |
---|
1453 |
| | |
---|
1454 | Yu 2008, passim.
| | |
---|
1455 |
| | |
---|
1456 |
| | |
---|
1457 | [52]
| | |
---|
1458 |
| | |
---|
1459 | Zehe et al. 2016, passim.
| | |
---|
1460 |
| | |
---|
1461 |
| | |
---|
1462 | [53]
| | |
---|
1463 |
| | |
---|
1464 | Mohammad / Turney 2013, passim.
| | |
---|
1465 |
| | |
---|
1466 |
| | |
---|
1467 | [54]
| | |
---|
1468 |
| | |
---|
1469 | Reagan et al.
| | |
---|
1470 | 2016, passim.
| | |
---|
1471 |
| | |
---|
1472 |
| | |
---|
1473 | [55]
| | |
---|
1474 |
| | |
---|
1475 | Vonnegut 2010 (2005), passim.
| | |
---|
1476 |
| | |
---|
1477 |
| | |
---|
1478 | [56]
| | |
---|
1479 |
| | |
---|
1480 | Project Gutenberg 1971-2019.
| | |
---|
1481 |
| | |
---|
1482 |
| | |
---|
1483 | [57]
| | |
---|
1484 |
| | |
---|
1485 | Samothrakis / Fasli 2015;
| | |
---|
1486 | Kim et al.
| | |
---|
1487 | 2017a; Kim et al. 2017b.
| | |
---|
1488 |
| | |
---|
1489 |
| | |
---|
1490 | [58]
| | |
---|
1491 |
| | |
---|
1492 | Strapparava / Valitutti 2004.
| | |
---|
1493 |
| | |
---|
1494 |
| | |
---|
1495 | [59]
| | |
---|
1496 |
| | |
---|
1497 | Kim et al. 2017a, passim.
| | |
---|
1498 |
| | |
---|
1499 |
| | |
---|
1500 | [60]
| | |
---|
1501 |
| | |
---|
1502 | Francis / Kucera 1979, passim.
| | |
---|
1503 |
| | |
---|
1504 |
| | |
---|
1505 |
| | |
---|
1506 | [61]
| | |
---|
1507 |
| | |
---|
1508 | Henny-Krahmer 2018, passim.
| | |
---|
1509 |
| | |
---|
1510 |
| | |
---|
1511 | [62]
| | |
---|
1512 |
| | |
---|
1513 | Baccianella et al. 2010.
| | |
---|
1514 |
| | |
---|
1515 |
| | |
---|
1516 |
| | |
---|
1517 | [63]
| | |
---|
1518 |
| | |
---|
1519 | Mohammad / Turney 2013.
| | |
---|
1520 |
| | |
---|
1521 |
| | |
---|
1522 | [64]
| | |
---|
1523 |
| | |
---|
1524 | Heuser et al. 2016, passim.
| | |
---|
1525 |
| | |
---|
1526 |
| | |
---|
1527 | [65]
| | |
---|
1528 |
| | |
---|
1529 | Historypin 2010-2017.
| | |
---|
1530 |
| | |
---|
1531 |
| | |
---|
1532 | [66]
| | |
---|
1533 |
| | |
---|
1534 | Bruggmann / Fabrikant 2014, passim.
| | |
---|
1535 |
| | |
---|
1536 |
| | |
---|
1537 | [67]
| | |
---|
1538 |
| | |
---|
1539 | Stone et al. 1968.
| | |
---|
1540 |
| | |
---|
1541 |
| | |
---|
1542 | [68]
| | |
---|
1543 |
| | |
---|
1544 | Taboada et al. 2006, passim; Taboada et al. 2008, passim.
| | |
---|
1545 |
| | |
---|
1546 |
| | |
---|
1547 | [69]
| | |
---|
1548 |
| | |
---|
1549 | Chen et al. 2012, passim.
| | |
---|
1550 |
| | |
---|
1551 |
| | |
---|
1552 | [70]
| | |
---|
1553 |
| | |
---|
1554 |
| | |
---|
1555 | Strapparava / Valitutti 2004.
| | |
---|
1556 |
| | |
---|
1557 |
| | |
---|
1558 | [71]
| | |
---|
1559 |
| | |
---|
1560 | Oceanic Exchanges 2017.
| | |
---|
1561 |
| | |
---|
1562 |
| | |
---|
1563 | [72]
| | |
---|
1564 |
| | |
---|
1565 | Marchetti et al. 2014, passim.
| | |
---|
1566 |
| | |
---|
1567 |
| | |
---|
1568 | [73]
| | |
---|
1569 |
| | |
---|
1570 | Sprugnoli et al. 2016, passim.
| | |
---|
1571 |
| | |
---|
1572 |
| | |
---|
1573 | [74]
| | |
---|
1574 |
| | |
---|
1575 | ALCIDE Demo 2014-2015.
| | |
---|
1576 |
| | |
---|
1577 |
| | |
---|
1578 | [75]
| | |
---|
1579 |
| | |
---|
1580 | Baccianella et al. 2010, passim.
| | |
---|
1581 |
| | |
---|
1582 |
| | |
---|
1583 | [76]
| | |
---|
1584 |
| | |
---|
1585 | Pianta et al. 2002, passim.
| | |
---|
1586 |
| | |
---|
1587 |
| | |
---|
1588 | [77]
| | |
---|
1589 |
| | |
---|
1590 | Buechel et al. 2017, passim.
| | |
---|
1591 |
| | |
---|
1592 |
| | |
---|
1593 | [78]
| | |
---|
1594 |
| | |
---|
1595 | Buechel et al. 2016, p. 54, p. 59.
| | |
---|
1596 |
| | |
---|
1597 |
| | |
---|
1598 | [79]
| | |
---|
1599 |
| | |
---|
1600 | Deutsches Textarchiv 2007-2019.
| | |
---|
1601 |
| | |
---|
1602 |
| | |
---|
1603 | [80]
| | |
---|
1604 |
| | |
---|
1605 | Leemans et al. 2017, passim.
| | |
---|
1606 |
| | |
---|
1607 |
| | |
---|
1608 | [81]
| | |
---|
1609 |
| | |
---|
1610 | Pennebaker et al. 2007.
| | |
---|
1611 |
| | |
---|
1612 |
| | |
---|
1613 | [82]
| | |
---|
1614 |
| | |
---|
1615 | Ingermanson / Economy 2009, p.
| | |
---|
1616 | 107.
| | |
---|
1617 |
| | |
---|
1618 |
| | |
---|
1619 | [83]
| | |
---|
1620 |
| | |
---|
1621 | Agarwal et al. 2013;
| | |
---|
1622 | Elson et al. 2011.
| | |
---|
1623 |
| | |
---|
1624 |
| | |
---|
1625 | [84]
| | |
---|
1626 |
| | |
---|
1627 | Nalisnick / Baird 2013a, passim.
| | |
---|
1628 |
| | |
---|
1629 |
| | |
---|
1630 | [85]
| | |
---|
1631 |
| | |
---|
1632 | Nielsen 2011, passim.
| | |
---|
1633 |
| | |
---|
1634 |
| | |
---|
1635 | [86]
| | |
---|
1636 |
| | |
---|
1637 | Nalisnick / Baird 2013b, passim.
| | |
---|
1638 |
| | |
---|
1639 |
| | |
---|
1640 | [87]
| | |
---|
1641 |
| | |
---|
1642 | Marvel et al. 2011.
| | |
---|
1643 |
| | |
---|
1644 |
| | |
---|
1645 | [88]
| | |
---|
1646 |
| | |
---|
1647 | Elsner 2012, passim;
| | |
---|
1648 | Elsner 2015, passim.
| | |
---|
1649 |
| | |
---|
1650 |
| | |
---|
1651 | [89]
| | |
---|
1652 |
| | |
---|
1653 | Kim / Klinger 2018, passim.
| | |
---|
1654 |
| | |
---|
1655 |
| | |
---|
1656 | [90]
| | |
---|
1657 |
| | |
---|
1658 | REMAN - Relational Emotion Annotation for Fiction. Corpus 2018.
| | |
---|
1659 |
| | |
---|
1660 |
| | |
---|
1661 | [91]
| | |
---|
1662 |
| | |
---|
1663 | Barth et al. 2018, passim.
| | |
---|
1664 |
| | |
---|
1665 |
| | |
---|
1666 | [92]
| | |
---|
1667 |
| | |
---|
1668 | Jhavar / Mirza
| | |
---|
1669 | 2018, passim.
| | |
---|
1670 |
| | |
---|
1671 |
| | |
---|
1672 | [93]
| | |
---|
1673 |
| | |
---|
1674 | EMoFiel: Emotion Mapping of Fictional Relationship 2018.
| | |
---|
1675 |
| | |
---|
1676 |
| | |
---|
1677 | [94]
| | |
---|
1678 |
| | |
---|
1679 | Plutchik 1991, passim.
| | |
---|
1680 |
| | |
---|
1681 |
| | |
---|
1682 | [95]
| | |
---|
1683 |
| | |
---|
1684 | Russell 1980, passim.
| | |
---|
1685 |
| | |
---|
1686 |
| | |
---|
1687 | [96]
| | |
---|
1688 |
| | |
---|
1689 | Egloff et al. 2018, passim.
| | |
---|
1690 |
| | |
---|
1691 |
| | |
---|
1692 | [97]
| | |
---|
1693 |
| | |
---|
1694 | Patti et al. 2015.
| | |
---|
1695 |
| | |
---|
1696 |
| | |
---|
1697 | [98]
| | |
---|
1698 |
| | |
---|
1699 | Cambria et al. 2012, passim.
| | |
---|
1700 |
| | |
---|
1701 |
| | |
---|
1702 | [99]
| | |
---|
1703 |
| | |
---|
1704 | Kim / Klinger 2019b, passim.
| | |
---|
1705 |
| | |
---|
1706 |
| | |
---|
1707 | [100]
| | |
---|
1708 |
| | |
---|
1709 | Kim / Klinger
| | |
---|
1710 | 2019a, passim.
| | |
---|
1711 |
| | |
---|
1712 |
| | |
---|
1713 | [101]
| | |
---|
1714 |
| | |
---|
1715 | Their
| | |
---|
1716 | analysis is based on Van Meel 1995 we mentioned in
| | |
---|
1717 | Section 3.
| | |
---|
1718 |
| | |
---|
1719 |
| | |
---|
1720 | [102]
| | |
---|
1721 |
| | |
---|
1722 | Rinaldi et al. 2013, passim.
| | |
---|
1723 |
| | |
---|
1724 |
| | |
---|
1725 | [103]
| | |
---|
1726 |
| | |
---|
1727 | Zhuravlev et al. 2014, passim.
| | |
---|
1728 |
| | |
---|
1729 |
| | |
---|
1730 | [104]
| | |
---|
1731 |
| | |
---|
1732 | Jafari et al. 2016, passim.
| | |
---|
1733 |
| | |
---|
1734 |
| | |
---|
1735 | [105]
| | |
---|
1736 |
| | |
---|
1737 | Anderson / McMaster 1986, passim.
| | |
---|
1738 |
| | |
---|
1739 |
| | |
---|
1740 | [106]
| | |
---|
1741 |
| | |
---|
1742 | Heise 1965, passim.
| | |
---|
1743 |
| | |
---|
1744 |
| | |
---|
1745 | [107]
| | |
---|
1746 |
| | |
---|
1747 | Anderson / McMaster 1982;
| | |
---|
1748 | Anderson / McMaster 1993.
| | |
---|
1749 |
| | |
---|
1750 |
| | |
---|
1751 | [108]
| | |
---|
1752 |
| | |
---|
1753 | Alm / Sproat 2005, passim.
| | |
---|
1754 |
| | |
---|
1755 |
| | |
---|
1756 | [109]
| | |
---|
1757 |
| | |
---|
1758 | Mohammad 2011, passim;
| | |
---|
1759 | Mohammad
| | |
---|
1760 | 2012, passim.
| | |
---|
1761 |
| | |
---|
1762 |
| | |
---|
1763 | [110]
| | |
---|
1764 |
| | |
---|
1765 | Klinger et al. 2016, passim.
| | |
---|
1766 |
| | |
---|
1767 |
| | |
---|
1768 | [111]
| | |
---|
1769 |
| | |
---|
1770 | Kim et al. 2017b, passim.
| | |
---|
1771 |
| | |
---|
1772 |
| | |
---|
1773 | [112]
| | |
---|
1774 |
| | |
---|
1775 | Freytag 1863, passim.
| | |
---|
1776 |
| | |
---|
1777 |
| | |
---|
1778 | [113]
| | |
---|
1779 |
| | |
---|
1780 | Kakkonen /
| | |
---|
1781 | Galic Kakkonen 2011, passim.
| | |
---|
1782 |
| | |
---|
1783 |
| | |
---|
1784 | [114]
| | |
---|
1785 |
| | |
---|
1786 | Koolen 2018, passim.
| | |
---|
1787 |
| | |
---|
1788 |
| | |
---|
1789 | [115]
| | |
---|
1790 |
| | |
---|
1791 | Boot et al.
| | |
---|
1792 | 2017.
| | |
---|
1793 |
| | |
---|
1794 |
| | |
---|
1795 | [116]
| | |
---|
1796 |
| | |
---|
1797 | Kraicer / Piper 2019, passim.
| | |
---|
1798 |
| | |
---|
1799 |
| | |
---|
1800 | [117]
| | |
---|
1801 |
| | |
---|
1802 | Liu et al. 2010, passim.
| | |
---|
1803 |
| | |
---|
1804 |
| | |
---|
1805 | [118]
| | |
---|
1806 |
| | |
---|
1807 | Morin / Acerbi 2017, passim.
| | |
---|
1808 |
| | |
---|
1809 |
| | |
---|
1810 | [119]
| | |
---|
1811 |
| | |
---|
1812 | Google Books Ngram Viewer 2012.
| | |
---|
1813 |
| | |
---|
1814 |
| | |
---|
1815 | [120]
| | |
---|
1816 |
| | |
---|
1817 | Pennebaker et al. 2007.
| | |
---|
1818 |
| | |
---|
1819 |
| | |
---|
1820 | [121]
| | |
---|
1821 |
| | |
---|
1822 | Bentley et al. 2014, passim.
| | |
---|
1823 |
| | |
---|
1824 |
| | |
---|
1825 | [122]
| | |
---|
1826 |
| | |
---|
1827 | Morin / Acerbi 2017, passim.
| | |
---|
1828 |
| | |
---|
1829 |
| | |
---|
1830 | [123]
| | |
---|
1831 |
| | |
---|
1832 | Mäntylä et al. 2018, passim.
| | |
---|
1833 |
| | |
---|
1834 |
| | |
---|
1835 | [124]
| | |
---|
1836 |
| | |
---|
1837 | Anderson / McMaster 1982, passim.
| | |
---|
1838 |
| | |
---|
1839 |
| | |
---|
1840 | [125]
| | |
---|
1841 |
| | |
---|
1842 | Reed 2018, passim.
| | |
---|
1843 |
| | |
---|
1844 |
| | |
---|
1845 | [126]
| | |
---|
1846 |
| | |
---|
1847 | Heuser
| | |
---|
1848 | et al. 2016, passim.
| | |
---|
1849 |
| | |
---|
1850 |
| | |
---|
1851 | [127]
| | |
---|
1852 |
| | |
---|
1853 | Morin and Acerbi
| | |
---|
1854 | 2017, passim.
| | |
---|
1855 |
| | |
---|
1856 |
| | |
---|
1857 | [128]
| | |
---|
1858 |
| | |
---|
1859 | Da
| | |
---|
1860 | 2019, passim.
| | |
---|
1861 |
| | |
---|
1862 |
| | |
---|
1863 |
| | |
---|
1864 |
| | |
---|
1865 |
| | |
---|
1866 |
| | |
---|
1867 | Bibliographic References
| | |
---|
1868 |
| | |
---|
1869 |
| | |
---|
1870 | Muhammad Abdul-Mageed / Lyle Ungar: EmoNet: Fine-grained emotion detection with
| | |
---|
1871 | gated recurrent neural networks. In: Proceedings of the 55th Annual Meeting of the
| | |
---|
1872 | Association for Computational Linguistics. (ACL: 55, Vancouver, 30.07.-04.08.2017)
| | |
---|
1873 | New York, NY 2017, i 1, pp. 718–728. DOI: 10.18653/v1/P17-1067Apoorv Agarwal / Anup Kotalwar / Owen Rambow: Automatic extraction of social
| | |
---|
1874 | networks from literary text: A case study on Alice in Wonderland. In: Proceedings
| | |
---|
1875 | of
| | |
---|
1876 | the Sixth International Joint Conference on Natural Language Processing. (IJCLP: 6,
| | |
---|
1877 | Nagoya 14.-18.10.2013) Nagoya 2013, pp. 1202–1208. [online]
| | |
---|
1878 |
| | |
---|
1879 | Cecilia Ovesdotter Alm / Richard Sproat: Emotional sequencing and development in
| | |
---|
1880 | fairy tales. In: Affective computing and intelligent interaction. First international
| | |
---|
1881 | conference. Proceedings. Ed. by Jianhua Tao et al. (ACII’05, Beijing,
| | |
---|
1882 | 22.-24.10.2005) Berlin et al. 2005, pp. 668–674. [Nachweis im GVK]
| | |
---|
1883 | ALCIDE (Analysis of Language and Content In a Digital Environment). Demo. Ed. by Center
| | |
---|
1884 | for Information Technology Digital Humanities, Fondazione Bruno Kessler / Italian-German
| | |
---|
1885 | Historical Institute.
| | |
---|
1886 | In: fbk.eu. Alcide Demo. Trento 2014-2015. [online]
| | |
---|
1887 | Clifford W. Anderson / George E. McMaster: Computer assisted modeling of affective
| | |
---|
1888 | tone in written documents. In: Computers and the Humanities 16 (1982), i. 1, pp. 1–9.
| | |
---|
1889 | [Nachweis im GVK]
| | |
---|
1890 | Clifford W. Anderson / George E. McMaster: Modeling emotional tone in stories
| | |
---|
1891 | using tension levels and categorical states. In: Computers and the Humanities 20
| | |
---|
1892 | (1986), i. 1, pp. 3–9. [Nachweis im GVK]
| | |
---|
1893 | Clifford W. Anderson / George E. McMaster: Emotional tone in Peter Rabbit before
| | |
---|
1894 | and after simplification. In: Empirical Studies of the Arts 11 (1993), i. 2, pp.
| | |
---|
1895 | 177–185. [Nachweis im GVK]
| | |
---|
1896 | Aristotle: Poetics. Penguin 1996. (= Penguin Classics)Stefano Baccianella / Andrea Esuli / Fabrizio Sebastiani: Sentiwordnet 3.0: An
| | |
---|
1897 | enhanced lexical resource for sentiment analysis and opinion mining. In: Proceedings
| | |
---|
1898 | of the 7th International Conference on Language Resources and Evaluation. (LREC’10:
| | |
---|
1899 | 7, Valetta, 17.05.-23.05.2010) Paris 2010, pp. 2200–2204. PDF. [online]
| | |
---|
1900 | P. Matthijs Bal / Martijn Veltkamp: How does fiction reading influence empathy? An
| | |
---|
1901 | experimental investigation on the role of emotional transportation. In: PLOS ONE 8
| | |
---|
1902 | (2013), i. 1, p. e55341. Article from 30.01.2013. DOI: 10.1371/journal.pone.0055341Lisa Feldman Barrett: Discrete emotions or dimensions? The role of valence focus
| | |
---|
1903 | and arousal focus. In: Cognition & Emotion 12 (1998), i. 4, pp. 579–599.
| | |
---|
1904 | [Nachweis im GVK]
| | |
---|
1905 | Lisa Feldman Barrett: How emotions are made: The secret life of the brain. Boston
| | |
---|
1906 | et al. 2017. [Nachweis im GVK]
| | |
---|
1907 | Linda Barros / Pilar Rodriguez / Alvaro Ortigosa: Automatic classification of
| | |
---|
1908 | literature pieces by emotion detection: a study on quevedo’s poetry. In: 2013 Humaine
| | |
---|
1909 | Association Conference on Affective Computing and Intelligent Interaction. (ACII
| | |
---|
1910 | 2013: 5, Geneva, 02.-05.09.2013), Piscataway, NJ 2013, pp. 141–146. [Nachweis im GVK]
| | |
---|
1911 | Florian Barth / Evgeny Kim / Sandra Murr / Roman Klinger: A reporting tool for
| | |
---|
1912 | relational visualization and analysis of character mentions in literature. In: DHd
| | |
---|
1913 | 2018: Kritik der digitalen Vernunft : Konferenzabstracts. Ed. by Georg Vogeler. (DHd
| | |
---|
1914 | 2018: 5, Köln, 26.02.-02.03.2018), Cologne 2018, pp. 123–127. PDF. [online] [Nachweis im GVK]
| | |
---|
1915 | James Barton: Interpreting character emotions for literature comprehension. In:
| | |
---|
1916 | Journal of Adolescent & Adult Literacy 40 (1996), i. 1, pp. 22–28.
| | |
---|
1917 | [Nachweis im GVK]
| | |
---|
1918 | Alexander R. Bentley / Alberto Acerbi / Paul Ormerod / Vasileios Lampos: Books
| | |
---|
1919 | average previous decade of economic misery. In: PLOS ONE 9 (2014), i. 1, p. e83147.
| | |
---|
1920 | Article from 08.01.2014. DOI: 10.1371/journal.pone.0083147David M. Berry: Introduction: Understanding the digital humanities. In:
| | |
---|
1921 | Understanding digital humanities. Ed. by David M. Berry. Houndmills et al. 2012, pp.
| | |
---|
1922 | 1–20. [Nachweis im GVK]
| | |
---|
1923 | Peter Boot / Hanna Zijlstra / Rinie Geenen: The Dutch translation of the
| | |
---|
1924 | linguistic inquiry and word count (LIWC) 2007 dictionary. In: Dutch Journal of
| | |
---|
1925 | Applied Linguistics 6 (2017), i. 1, pp. 65–76. [Nachweis im GVK]
| | |
---|
1926 | Damian Borth / Rongrong Ji / Tao Chen / Thomas Breuel / Shih-Fu Chang: Large-scale
| | |
---|
1927 | visual sentiment ontology and detectors using adjective noun pairs. In: Proceedings
| | |
---|
1928 | of the 21st ACM International Conference on Multimedia. (MM '13: 21, Barcelona,
| | |
---|
1929 | 21.-25.10.2013) New York, NY 2013, pp. 223–232. [Nachweis im GVK]
| | |
---|
1930 | Margaret M. Bradley / Peter J. Lang: Measuring emotion: the self-assessment
| | |
---|
1931 | manikin and the semantic differential. In: Journal of behavior therapy and
| | |
---|
1932 | experimental psychiatry 25 (1994), i. 1, pp. 49–59. [Nachweis im GVK]
| | |
---|
1933 | André Bruggmann / Sara Irina Fabrikant: Spatializing a digital text archive about
| | |
---|
1934 | history. In: Workshop on Geographic Information Observatories 2014 : proceedings.
| | |
---|
1935 | Ed.
| | |
---|
1936 | by Krzysztof Janowicz / Benjamin Adams / Grant McKenzie / Tomi Kauppinen. (GIO 2014
| | |
---|
1937 | /
| | |
---|
1938 | GIScience: 8, Vienna, 23.09.2014) Aachen 2014, pp. 6–14. (CEUR Workshop Proceedings,
| | |
---|
1939 | 1273) PDF. [online]
| | |
---|
1940 | Jennings Bryant / Dolf Zillmann: Using television to alleviate boredom and stress:
| | |
---|
1941 | Selective exposure as a function of induced excitational states. In: Journal of
| | |
---|
1942 | Broadcasting & Electronic Media 28 (1984), i. 1, pp. 1–20. [Nachweis im GVK]
| | |
---|
1943 | Sven Buechel / Johannes Hellrich / Udo Hahn: Feelings from the past – adapting
| | |
---|
1944 | affective lexicons for historical emotion analysis. In: Proceedings of the Workshop
| | |
---|
1945 | on Language Technology Resources and Tools for Digital Humanities. (LT4DH, Osaka,
| | |
---|
1946 | 11.12.2016) Stroudsburg, PA 2016, pp. 54–61. PDF. [online]
| | |
---|
1947 | Sven Buechel / Johannes Hellrich / Udo Hahn: The course of emotion in three
| | |
---|
1948 | centuries of german text – a methodological framework. In: Digital Humanities 2017:
| | |
---|
1949 | Conference Abstracts. Ed. by Rhian Lewis et al. (DH 2017, Montreal, 08.-11.08.2017)
| | |
---|
1950 | Montreal 2017, pp. 176–179. [online]
| | |
---|
1951 | Erik Cambria / Andrew Livingstone / Amir Hussain: The hourglass of emotions. In:
| | |
---|
1952 | Cognitive behavioural systems. Ed. by Anna Esposito et al. (COST 2102, Dresden,
| | |
---|
1953 | 21.-26.02.2011) Berlin 2012, pp. 144–157. [Nachweis im GVK]
| | |
---|
1954 | Annie T. Chen / Ayoung Yoon / Ryan Shaw: People, places and emotions: Visually
| | |
---|
1955 | representing historical context in oral testimonies. In: Proceedings of the Third
| | |
---|
1956 | Workshop on Computational Models of Narrative. (CMN’12: 3, Istanbul, 26.-27.05.2012),
| | |
---|
1957 | pp. 26–27. Cambridge, MA 2012. PDF. [online]
| | |
---|
1958 | Oceanic Exchanges: Tracing Global Information Networks in Historical Newspaper
| | |
---|
1959 | Repositories, 1840-1914. Ed. by Oceanic Exchanges Project Team. Boston, MA 2017.
| | |
---|
1960 | [online]
| | |
---|
1961 | Nan Z. Da: The computational case against computational literary studies. In:
| | |
---|
1962 | Critical Inquiry 45 (2019), i. 3, pp. 601–639. [Nachweis im GVK]
| | |
---|
1963 | Charles Darwin: The expression of emotion in animals and man. London 1872.
| | |
---|
1964 | [Nachweis im GVK]
| | |
---|
1965 | Deutsches Textarchiv. Grundlage für ein Referenzkorpus der neuhochdeutschen Sprache.
| | |
---|
1966 | Ed. by Berlin-Brandenburgischen Akademie der Wissenschaften.
| | |
---|
1967 | In: deutschestextarchiv.de. Berlin 2007-2019. [online]
| | |
---|
1968 | Maja Djikic / Keith Oatley / Sara Zoeterman / Jordan B. Peterson: On being moved
| | |
---|
1969 | by art: How reading fiction transforms the self. In: Creativity Research Journal 21
| | |
---|
1970 | (2009), i. 1, pp. 24–29. [Nachweis im GVK]
| | |
---|
1971 | Maja Djikic / Keith Oatley / Mihnea C. Moldoveanu: Reading other minds: Effects of
| | |
---|
1972 | literature on empathy. In: Scientific Study of Literature 3 (2013), i. 1, pp. 28–47.
| | |
---|
1973 | [Nachweis im GVK]
| | |
---|
1974 | Mattia Egloff / Antonio Lieto / Davide Picca: An ontological model for inferring
| | |
---|
1975 | psychological profiles and narrative roles of characters. In: Digital Humanities
| | |
---|
1976 | 2018: Puentes-Bridges. Book of Abstracts. Hg. von Jonathan Girón Palau / Isabel
| | |
---|
1977 | Galina Russell. (DH 2018, Mexico City, 26.-29.06.2018) Mexico City 2018, pp. 649–650.
| | |
---|
1978 | PDF. [online]
| | |
---|
1979 | Paul Ekman: Facial expression and emotion. In: American psychologist 48 (1993), i.
| | |
---|
1980 | 4, pp. 384–392. [Nachweis im GVK]
| | |
---|
1981 | Paul Ekman / Richard E. Sorenson / Wallace V. Friesen: Pan-cultural elements in
| | |
---|
1982 | facial displays of emotion. In: Science 164 (1969), i. 3875, pp. 86–88.
| | |
---|
1983 | [Nachweis im GVK]
| | |
---|
1984 | Micha Elsner: Character-based kernels for novelistic plot structure. In:
| | |
---|
1985 | Proceedings of the 13th Conference of the European Chapter of the Association for
| | |
---|
1986 | Computational Linguistics. (EACL’12: 13, Avignon, 23.-27.04.2012) Stroudsburg, PA
| | |
---|
1987 | 2012, pp. 634–644. PDF. [online]
| | |
---|
1988 | Micha Elsner: Abstract representations of plot structure. In: Linguistic Issues in
| | |
---|
1989 | Language Technology 12 (2015), i. 5. PDF. [online]
| | |
---|
1990 | David K. Elson / Nicholas Dames / Kathleen R. McKeown: Extracting social networks
| | |
---|
1991 | from literary fiction. In: Proceedings of the 48th Annual Meeting of the Association
| | |
---|
1992 | for Computational Linguistics. (ACL: 48, Uppsala, 11.-18.07.2010) Red Hook, NY 2011,
| | |
---|
1993 | pp. 138–147. PDF. [online] [Nachweis im GVK]
| | |
---|
1994 | EMoFiel: Emotion Mapping of Fictional Relationship. Ed. by Harshita Jhavar / Paramita
| | |
---|
1995 | Mirza, Max Planck Institute for Informatics.
| | |
---|
1996 | In: mpi-inf.mpg.de. EMoFiel. Saarbrücken 2018. [online]
| | |
---|
1997 | Winthrop Nelson Francis / Henry Kucera: Brown corpus manual. Preface to revised
| | |
---|
1998 | Edition. Providence, RI 1979. [online]
| | |
---|
1999 | Gustav Freytag: Die Technik des Dramas. Leipzig 1863. [Nachweis im GVK]
| | |
---|
2000 | Maria Gendron / Lisa Feldman Barrett: Reconstructing the past: A century of ideas
| | |
---|
2001 | about emotion in psychology. In: Emotion review 1 (2009), i. 4, pp. 316–339.
| | |
---|
2002 | [Nachweis im GVK]
| | |
---|
2003 | Maria Gendron / Debi Roberso / Jacoba Marietta van der Vyver / Lisa Feldman
| | |
---|
2004 | Barrett: Perceptions of emotion from facial expressions are not culturally universal:
| | |
---|
2005 | Evidence from a remote culture. In: Emotion 14 (2014), i. 2, pp. 251–262.
| | |
---|
2006 | [Nachweis im GVK]
| | |
---|
2007 | Google Books Ngram Viewer. Ed. by Google. In: http://storage.googleapis.com. Version
| | |
---|
2008 | 2. 2012. [online]
| | |
---|
2009 | David Reuben Jerome Heise: Semantic differential profiles for 1,000 most frequent
| | |
---|
2010 | English words. In: Psychological Monographs: General and Applied 79 (1965), i. 8,
| | |
---|
2011 | pp.
| | |
---|
2012 | 1–31. [Nachweis im GVK]
| | |
---|
2013 | Ulrike Edith Gerda Henny-Krahmer: Exploration of sentiments and genre in Spanish
| | |
---|
2014 | American novels. In: Digital Humanities 2018: Puentes-Bridges. Book of Abstracts.
| | |
---|
2015 | Hg.
| | |
---|
2016 | von Jonathan Girón Palau / Isabel Galina Russell. (DH 2018, Mexico City,
| | |
---|
2017 | 26.-29.06.2018) Mexico City 2018, pp. 399–403. PDF. [online]
| | |
---|
2018 | Ryan Heuser / Franco Moretti / Erik Steiner: The emotions of London. Stanford
| | |
---|
2019 | 2016. (= Literary Lab Pamphlets, 13) PDF.[online]
| | |
---|
2020 | Mapping emotions in Victorian London. Ed. by. Historypin. In: historypin.org. New
| | |
---|
2021 | Orleans et al. 2010-2017. [online]
| | |
---|
2022 | Hillis J. Miller: Text; Action; Space; Emotion in Conrad’s Nostromo. In: Exploring
| | |
---|
2023 | Text and Emotions. Ed. by Lars Saetre / Lombardo / Julien Zanetta. Aarhus 2014, pp.
| | |
---|
2024 | 91–117. [Nachweis im GVK]
| | |
---|
2025 | Patrick Colm Hogan: Fictions and feelings: On the place of literature in the study
| | |
---|
2026 | of emotion. In: Emotion Review 2 (2010), i. 2, pp. 184–195. [Nachweis im GVK]
| | |
---|
2027 | Patrick Colm Hogan: What Literature Teaches Us about Emotion. New York, NY 2011.
| | |
---|
2028 | [Nachweis im GVK]
| | |
---|
2029 | David Lowell Hoover / Jonathan Culpeper / Kieran O’Halloran: Digital literary
| | |
---|
2030 | studies: Corpus Approaches to Poetry, Prose, and Drama. New York, NY 2014.
| | |
---|
2031 | [Nachweis im GVK]
| | |
---|
2032 | Randy Ingermanson / Peter Economy. Writing fiction for dummies. Hoboken, NJ 2009.
| | |
---|
2033 | [Nachweis im GVK]
| | |
---|
2034 | Sajad Jafari / Julien Clinton Sprott / Seyed Mohammad Reza Hashemi Golpayegani:
| | |
---|
2035 | Layla and Majnun: A complex love story. In: Nonlinear Dynamics 83 (2016), i. 1, pp.
| | |
---|
2036 | 615–622. [Nachweis im GVK]
| | |
---|
2037 | Harshita Jhavar / Paramita Mirza: EMOFIEL: Mapping emotions of relationships in a
| | |
---|
2038 | story. In: Companion Proceedings of the The Web Conference 2018. (WWW’18, Lyon,
| | |
---|
2039 | 23.-27.04.2018) Geneva 2018, pp. 243–246. DOI: 10.1145/3184558.3186989Matthew Lee Jockers / Ted Underwood: Text-mining the humanities. In: A New
| | |
---|
2040 | Companion to Digital Humanities. Ed. by Susan Schreibman / Ray Siemens / John
| | |
---|
2041 | Unsworth. Pondicherry 2016, pp. 291–306. [Nachweis im GVK]
| | |
---|
2042 | Dan R. Johnson: Transportation into a story increases empathy, prosocial behavior,
| | |
---|
2043 | and perceptual bias toward fearful expressions. In: Personality and Individual
| | |
---|
2044 | Differences 52 (2012), i. 2, pp. 150–155. [Nachweis im GVK]
| | |
---|
2045 | Philip Nicholas Johnson-Laird / Keith Oatley: The language of emotions: An
| | |
---|
2046 | analysis of a semantic field. In: Cognition and emotion 3 (1989), i. 2, pp. 81–123.
| | |
---|
2047 | [Nachweis im GVK]
| | |
---|
2048 | Philip Nicholas Johnson-Laird / Keith Oatley: Emotions in Music, Literature, and
| | |
---|
2049 | Film. In: Handbook of emotions. Ed. by Lisa Feldman Barret / Michael Lewis /
| | |
---|
2050 | Jeannette M. Haviland-Jones. 4. edition. New York, NY et al. 2016. pp. 82–97.
| | |
---|
2051 | [Nachweis im GVK]
| | |
---|
2052 | Tuomo Kakkonen / Gordana Galic Kakkonen: Sentiprofiler: Creating comparable visual
| | |
---|
2053 | profiles of sentimental content in texts. In: Proceedings of the Workshop on Language
| | |
---|
2054 | Technologies for Digital Humanities and Cultural Heritage. Ed. by Cristina Vertan
| | |
---|
2055 | / Milena Slavcheva / Petya Osenova / Stelios Piperidis. (DigHum / RANLP: 8, Hissar,
| | |
---|
2056 | 16.09.2011) Shoumen 2011, pp. 62–69. PDF. [online]
| | |
---|
2057 | [Nachweis im GVK]
| | |
---|
2058 | Evgeny Kim / Roman Klinger: Who feels what and why? Annotation of a literature
| | |
---|
2059 | corpus with semantic roles of emotions. In: Proceedings of the 27th International
| | |
---|
2060 | Conference on Computational Linguistics. (COLING: 27, Santa Fe, NM, 20.-26.08.2018)
| | |
---|
2061 | Stroudsburg, PA 2018, pp. 1345–1359. PDF. [online]
| | |
---|
2062 | Evgeny Kim / Roman Klinger (2019a): An analysis of emotion communication channels
| | |
---|
2063 | in fan-fiction: Towards emotional storytelling. In: Proceedings of the Second
| | |
---|
2064 | Workshop of Storytelling. Ed. by Francis Ferraro / Ting-Hao ›Kenneth‹ Huang / Stephanie
| | |
---|
2065 | M. Lukin / Margaret Mitchell. (Florence, 01.08.2019) Stroudsburg, PA 2019. DOI: 10.18653/v1/W19-3406Evgeny Kim / Roman Klinger (2019b): Frowning Frodo, wincing Leia, and a seriously
| | |
---|
2066 | great friendship: Learning to classify emotional relationships of fictional
| | |
---|
2067 | characters. In: Proceedings of the 2019 Conference of the North American Chapter of
| | |
---|
2068 | the Association for Computational Linguistics: Human Language Technologies. Volume
| | |
---|
2069 | 1,
| | |
---|
2070 | Long and Short Papers. (NAACL-HLT, Minneapolis, MN, 02.-07.06.2019) Stroudsburg, PA
| | |
---|
2071 | 2019, pp. 647–653. DOI: 10.18653/v1/N19-1067Evgeny Kim / Sebastian Padó / Roman Klinger (2017a): Investigating the
| | |
---|
2072 | relationship between literary genres and emotional plot development. In: Joint SIGHUM
| | |
---|
2073 | Workshop on Computational Linguistics for Cultural Heritage, Social Sciences,
| | |
---|
2074 | Humanities and Literature - proceedings of the workshop. (SIGHUM, Vancouver, 04.08.2017)
| | |
---|
2075 | Stroudsburg, PA 2017, pp. 17–26. DOI: 10.18653/v1/W17-2203Evgeny Kim / Sebastian Padó / Roman Klinger (2017b): Prototypical emotion
| | |
---|
2076 | developments in adventures, romances, and mystery stories. In: Digital Humanities
| | |
---|
2077 | 2017: Conference Abstracts. Ed. by Rhian Lewis / Cecily Raynor / Dominic Forest /
| | |
---|
2078 | Michael Sinatra / Stéfan Sinclair. (DH 2017, Montreal, 08.-11.08.2017) Montreal 2017,
| | |
---|
2079 | pp. 288–291. PDF. [online]
| | |
---|
2080 | Suin Kim / JinYeong Bak / Alice Haeyun Oh: Do you feel what I feel? Social aspects
| | |
---|
2081 | of emotions in twitter conversations. In: Proceedings of the Sixth International AAAI
| | |
---|
2082 | Conference on Weblogs and Social Media. (ICWSM: 6, Dublin 04.-07.12.2012) Palo Alto,
| | |
---|
2083 | CA 2012, pp. 495–498. [Nachweis im GVK]
| | |
---|
2084 | Roman Klinger / Surayya Samat Suliya / Nils Reiter: Automatic Emotion Detection
| | |
---|
2085 | for Quantitative Literary Studies – A case study based on Franz Kafka’s “Das Schloss”
| | |
---|
2086 | and “Amerika”. In: Digital Humanities 2016: Conference Abstracts. Ed. by Maciej Eder
| | |
---|
2087 | / Jan Rybicki. (DH 2016, Kraków. 11.-16.07.2016) Kraków 2016, pp. 826–828. PDF. [online]
| | |
---|
2088 | Corina Koolen: Women’s books versus books by women. Digital Humanities 2018:
| | |
---|
2089 | Puentes-Bridges. Book of Abstracts. Hg. von Jonathan Girón Palau / Isabel Galina
| | |
---|
2090 | Russell. (DH 2018, Mexico City, 26.-29.06.2018) Mexico City 2018, pp. 219–222. PDF.
| | |
---|
2091 | [online]
| | |
---|
2092 | Eve Kraicer / Andrew Piper: Social characters: The hierarchy of gender in
| | |
---|
2093 | contemporary English-language fiction. In: Journal of Cultural Analytics (2019).
| | |
---|
2094 | Article from 30.01.2019. DOI: 10.22148/16.032Päivi Kuivalainen: Emotions in narrative: A linguistic study of Katherine
| | |
---|
2095 | Mansfield’s short fiction. In: The Electronic Journal of the Department of English
| | |
---|
2096 | at
| | |
---|
2097 | the University of Helsinki 5 (2009). [online]
| | |
---|
2098 | Richard A. Lanham: The electronic word: Literary study and the digital revolution.
| | |
---|
2099 | In: New Literary History 20 (1989), i. 2, pp. 265–290. [Nachweis im GVK]
| | |
---|
2100 | Randy J. Larsen / Edward Diener: Promises and problems with the circumplex model
| | |
---|
2101 | of emotion. In: Emotion. Ed. by Margaret S. Clark. (= Review of personality and
| | |
---|
2102 | social psychology, 13) Newbury Park et al. 1992, pp. 25–29. [Nachweis im GVK]
| | |
---|
2103 | Inger Leemans / Janneke M. van der Zwaan / Isa Maks / Erika Kuijpers / Kristine
| | |
---|
2104 | Steenbergh: Mining embodied emotions: a comparative analysis of sentiment and emotion
| | |
---|
2105 | in dutch texts, 1600–1800. In: Digital Humanities Quaterly 11 (2017), i. 4. [online]
| | |
---|
2106 | Bing Liu: Sentiment Analysis: mining opinions, sentiments, and emotions. New York,
| | |
---|
2107 | NY 2015. [Nachweis im GVK]
| | |
---|
2108 | Bing Liu: Sentiment analysis and subjectivity. In: Handbook of natural language
| | |
---|
2109 | processing. Ed. by Nitin Indurkhya / Fred Jacob Damerau. 2. edition. Boca Raton, FL
| | |
---|
2110 | 2010, pp. 627–666. [Nachweis im GVK]
| | |
---|
2111 | Mika V. Mäntylä / Daniel Graziotin / Miikka Kuutila: The evolution of sentiment
| | |
---|
2112 | analysis – a review of research topics, venues, and top cited papers. In: Computer
| | |
---|
2113 | Science Review 27 (2018), pp. 16–32. [Nachweis im GVK]
| | |
---|
2114 | Raymond A. Mar / Keith Oatley / Maja Djikic / Justin Mullin: Emotion and narrative
| | |
---|
2115 | fiction: Interactive influences before, during, and after reading. In: Cognition
| | |
---|
2116 | & Emotion 25 (2011), i. 5, pp. 818–833. [Nachweis im GVK]
| | |
---|
2117 | Alessandro Marchetti / Rachele Sprugnoli / Sara Tonelli: Sentiment analysis for
| | |
---|
2118 | the humanities: the case of historical texts. In: Digital Humanities 2014: Conference
| | |
---|
2119 | Abstracts. (DH 2014, Lausanne 08.-12.07.2014), Lausanne 2014, pp. 254–257. PDF. [online] [Nachweis im GVK]
| | |
---|
2120 | Seth A. Marvel / Jon Kleinberg / Robert D. Kleinberg / Steven H. Strogatz:
| | |
---|
2121 | Continuous-time model of structural balance. In: Proceedings of the National Academy
| | |
---|
2122 | of Sciences 108 (2011), i. 5, pp. 1771–1776. DOI: 10.1073/pnas.1013213108 [Nachweis im GVK]
| | |
---|
2123 | John D. Mayer / Richard D. Roberts / Sigal G. Barsade: Human abilities: Emotional
| | |
---|
2124 | intelligence. In: Annual Review of Psychology 59 (2008), i. 1, pp. 507–536.
| | |
---|
2125 | [Nachweis im GVK]
| | |
---|
2126 | Jacques M. van Meel: Representing emotions in literature and paintings: a
| | |
---|
2127 | comparative analysis. In: Poetics 23 (1995), i. 1–2, pp. 159–176. [Nachweis im GVK]
| | |
---|
2128 | Saif M. Mohammad: From once upon a time to happily ever after: Tracking emotions
| | |
---|
2129 | in novels and fairy tales. In: Proceedings of the 5th ACL-HLT Workshop on Language
| | |
---|
2130 | Technology for Cultural Heritage, Social Sciences, and Humanities. Ed. by Kalliopi
| | |
---|
2131 | Zervanou / Piroska Lendvai. (ACL-HT: 5, Portland, OR, 23.-24.06.2011) Stroudsburg,
| | |
---|
2132 | PA
| | |
---|
2133 | 2011, pp. 105–114. PDF. [online]
| | |
---|
2134 | Saif M. Mohammad: From once upon a time to happily ever after: Tracking emotions
| | |
---|
2135 | in mail and books. In: Decision Support Systems 53 (2012), i. 4, pp. 730–741.
| | |
---|
2136 | [Nachweis im GVK]
| | |
---|
2137 | Saif M. Mohammad / Peter D. Turney: Crowdsourcing a word–emotion association
| | |
---|
2138 | lexicon. In: Computational Intelligence 29 (2013), i. 3, pp. 436–465.
| | |
---|
2139 | [Nachweis im GVK]
| | |
---|
2140 | Franco Moretti: Graphs, maps, trees: abstract models for a literary history.
| | |
---|
2141 | London et al. 2005. [Nachweis im GVK]
| | |
---|
2142 | Olivier Morin / Alberto Acerbi: Birth of the cool: a two-centuries decline in
| | |
---|
2143 | emotional expression in anglophone fiction. In: Cognition and Emotion 31 (2017), i.
| | |
---|
2144 | 8, pp. 1663–1675. [Nachweis im GVK]
| | |
---|
2145 | Eric T. Nalisnick / Henry S. Baird (2013a): Character-to-character sentiment
| | |
---|
2146 | analysis in shakespeare’s plays. In: Proceedings of the 51st Annual Meeting of the
| | |
---|
2147 | Association for Computational Linguistics. Ed. by Hinrich Schuetze / Pascale Fung
| | |
---|
2148 | / Massimo Poesio. 3 volumes. (ACL: 51, Sofia, 04.-09.08.2013) Red Hook, NY et al.
| | |
---|
2149 | 2013. Vol. 2: Short Papers, pp. 479–483. [online]
| | |
---|
2150 | [Nachweis im GVK]
| | |
---|
2151 | Eric T. Nalisnick / Henry S. Baird (2013b): Extracting sentiment networks from
| | |
---|
2152 | shakespeare’s plays. In: 12th International Conference on Document Analysis and
| | |
---|
2153 | Recognition. (ICDAR: 12, Washington, DC, 25.-28.08.2013) Piscataway, NJ 2013, pp.
| | |
---|
2154 | 758–762. [Nachweis im GVK]
| | |
---|
2155 | Finn Årup Nielsen: AFINN Sentiment Lexicon. In: corpustext.com. 2011. [online]
| | |
---|
2156 | Mary Beth Oliver: Tender affective states as predictors of entertainment
| | |
---|
2157 | preference. In: Journal of Communication 58 (2008), i. 1, pp. 40–61. [Nachweis im GVK]
| | |
---|
2158 | Viviana Patti / Federico Bertola / Antonio Lieto: Arsemotica for arsmeteo.org:
| | |
---|
2159 | Emotion-driven exploration of online art collections. In: The Twenty-Eighth
| | |
---|
2160 | International Florida Artificial Intelligence Research Society Conference. Ed. by
| | |
---|
2161 | Ingrid Russell / William Eberle. (FLAIRS: 28, Hollywood, 18.-28.05.2015) Palo Alto,
| | |
---|
2162 | CA, pp. 288–293. [Nachweis im GVK]
| | |
---|
2163 | James W. Pennebaker / Cindy K. Chung / Molly Ireland / Amy Gonzales / Roger
| | |
---|
2164 | J. Booth: The development and psychometric properties of LIWC2007. In: LIWC2007
| | |
---|
2165 | Manual. liwc.net. 2007. PDF. [online]
| | |
---|
2166 | Emanuele Pianta / Luisa Bentivogli / Christian Girardi: MultiWordNet: Developing
| | |
---|
2167 | an aligned multilingual database. In: Proceedings of 1st International Global WordNet
| | |
---|
2168 | Conference. (GWC: 1, Mysore, 21.-25.02.2002) Mysore 2002, pp. 293–302. [online]
| | |
---|
2169 | [Nachweis im GVK]
| | |
---|
2170 | Andrew Piper / Richard Jean So: Quantifying the weepy bestseller. In: The New
| | |
---|
2171 | Rebublic. Article from 18.12.2015. [online]
| | |
---|
2172 | Plato: Plato in Twelve Volumes. Cambridge, MA 1969. Siehe auch [Nachweis im GVK]
| | |
---|
2173 | Jonathan Posner / James Russell / Bradley Peterson: The circumplex model of affect:
| | |
---|
2174 | An integrative approach to affective neuroscience, cognitive development, and psychopathology.
| | |
---|
2175 | In: Development and psychopathology 17 (2005), i. 3, pp. 715-734. [Nachweis im GVK]
| | |
---|
2176 | Robert Plutchik: The Emotions. Revided edition. Lanham et al. 1991.
| | |
---|
2177 | [Nachweis im GVK]
| | |
---|
2178 | Robert Plutchik: Wheel of Emotions, 12.02.2011. In: Wikipedia, the free Encyclopedia:
| | |
---|
2179 | Robert
| | |
---|
2180 | Plutchik. Article from 20.09.2019. [online]
| | |
---|
2181 | Project Gutenberg. Ed. by Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation. In: gutenberg.org.
| | |
---|
2182 | Salt Lake City, UT 1971-. [online]
| | |
---|
2183 | Andrew J. Reagan / Lewis Mitchell / Dilan Kiley / Christopher M. Danforth /
| | |
---|
2184 | Peter Sheridan Dodds: The emotional arcs of stories are dominated by six basic
| | |
---|
2185 | shapes. In: EPJ Data Science 5 (2016), i. 1, pp. 31–43. DOI: 10.1140/epjds/s13688-016-0093-1Ethan Reed: Measured unrest in the poetry of the black arts movement. Digital
| | |
---|
2186 | Humanities 2018: Puentes-Bridges. Book of Abstracts. Hg. von Jonathan Girón Palau
| | |
---|
2187 | /
| | |
---|
2188 | Isabel Galina Russell. (DH 2018, Mexico City, 26.-29.06.2018) Mexico City 2018, pp.
| | |
---|
2189 | 477–478. PDF. [online]
| | |
---|
2190 | REMAN - Relational Emotion Annotation for Fiction. Relational EMotion ANnotation –
| | |
---|
2191 | a corpus with 1720 fictional text exceprts from the Project Gutenberg.
| | |
---|
2192 | Ed. by Evgeny Kim / Roman Klinger, Universität Stuttgart, Institut für Maschinelle
| | |
---|
2193 | Sprachverarbeitung. In: ims.uni-stuttgart.de. Institut für Maschinelle Sprachverarbeitung.
| | |
---|
2194 | Forschung. Ressourcen
| | |
---|
2195 | Korpora. Stuttgart 2018. [online]
| | |
---|
2196 | Marsha L. Richins: Measuring emotions in the consumption experience. In: Journal
| | |
---|
2197 | of consumer research 24 (1997), i. 2, pp. 127–146. [Nachweis im GVK]
| | |
---|
2198 | Sergio Rinaldi / Pietro Landi / Fabio Della Rossa: Small discoveries can have
| | |
---|
2199 | great consequences in love affairs: the case of Beauty and the Beast. In:
| | |
---|
2200 | International Journal of Bifurcation and Chaos 23 (2013), i. 11. [Nachweis im GVK]
| | |
---|
2201 | Jenefer Robinson: Deeper than reason: Emotion and its role in literature, music,
| | |
---|
2202 | and art. New York, NY 2005. [Nachweis im GVK]
| | |
---|
2203 | Catherine Sheldrick Ross: Finding without seeking: the information encounter in
| | |
---|
2204 | the context of reading for pleasure. In: Information Processing & Management 35
| | |
---|
2205 | (1999), i. 6., pp. 783–799. [Nachweis im GVK]
| | |
---|
2206 | James A. Russell: A circumplex model of affect. In: Journal of Personality and
| | |
---|
2207 | Social Psychology 39 (1980), pp. 1161–1178. [Nachweis im GVK]
| | |
---|
2208 | James A. Russell: Is there universal recognition of emotion from facial
| | |
---|
2209 | expression? A review of the cross-cultural studies. In: Psychological bulletin 115
| | |
---|
2210 | (1994), i. 1, pp. 102–141. [Nachweis im GVK]
| | |
---|
2211 | James A. Russell: Core affect and the psychological construction of emotion. In:
| | |
---|
2212 | Psychological review 110 (2003), i. 1, pp. 145–172. [Nachweis im GVK]
| | |
---|
2213 | James A. Russell / Lisa Feldman Barrett: Core affect, prototypical emotional
| | |
---|
2214 | episodes, and other things called emotion: dissecting the elephant. In: Journal of
| | |
---|
2215 | Personality and Social Psychology 76 (1999), i. 5, pp. 805–819. [Nachweis im GVK]
| | |
---|
2216 | James A. Russell / Jo-Anne Bachorowski / José-Miguel Fernández-Dols: Facial and
| | |
---|
2217 | vocal expressions of emotion. In: Annual review of psychology 54 (2003), i. 1, pp.
| | |
---|
2218 | 329–349. [Nachweis im GVK]
| | |
---|
2219 | Exploring Text and Emotions. Ed. by Lars Sætre / Patrizia Lombardo / Julien
| | |
---|
2220 | Zanetta (2014a). Aarhus 2014. [Nachweis im GVK]
| | |
---|
2221 | Lars Sætre / Patrizia Lombardo / Julien Zanetta (2014b): Text and Emotions. In:
| | |
---|
2222 | Exploring Text and Emotions. Ed. by Lars Sætre / Patrizia Lombardo / Julien Zanetta.
| | |
---|
2223 | Aarhus 2014, pp. 9–26. [Nachweis im GVK]
| | |
---|
2224 | Spyridon Samothrakis / Maria Fasli: Emotional sentence annotation helps predict
| | |
---|
2225 | fiction genre. In: PLOS ONE 10 (2015), i. 11, p. e0141922. Article from 02.11.2015.
| | |
---|
2226 | DOI: 10.1371/journal.pone.0141922Dalya Samur / Mattie Tops / Sander L. Koole: Does a single session of reading
| | |
---|
2227 | literary fiction prime enhanced mentalising performance? Four replication experiments
| | |
---|
2228 | of Kidd and Castano (2013). In: Cognition & Emotion 32 (2018), pp. 130–144.
| | |
---|
2229 | [Nachweis im GVK]
| | |
---|
2230 | Andrea Scarantino: The Phylosophy of Emotions and Its Impact on Affective
| | |
---|
2231 | Sciences. In: Handbook of emotions. Ed. by Lisa Feldman Barret / Michael Lewis /
| | |
---|
2232 | Jeannette M. Haviland-Jones. 4. edition. New York, NY et al. 2016. pp. 3–49.
| | |
---|
2233 | [Nachweis im GVK]
| | |
---|
2234 | Klaus R. Scherer: What are emotions? And how can they be measured? In: Social
| | |
---|
2235 | Science Information 44 (2005), i. 4, pp. 695–729. [Nachweis im GVK]
| | |
---|
2236 | Susan Schreibman / Ray Siemens / John Unsworth: A New Companion to Digital
| | |
---|
2237 | Humanities. Chichester et al. 2015/2016. [Nachweis im GVK]
| | |
---|
2238 | Norbert Schwarz: Emotion, cognition, and decision making. In: Cognition &
| | |
---|
2239 | Emotion 14 (2000), i. 4, pp. 433–440. [Nachweis im GVK]
| | |
---|
2240 | Herman Smith / Andreas Schneider: Critiquing models of emotions. In: Sociological
| | |
---|
2241 | Methods & Research 37 (2009), i. 4, pp. 560–589. [Nachweis im GVK]
| | |
---|
2242 | Mohammad Soleymani / David Garcia / Brendan Jou / Björn Schuller / Shih-Fu Chang /
| | |
---|
2243 | Maja Pantic: A survey of multimodal sentiment analysis. In: Image and Vision
| | |
---|
2244 | Computing 65 (2017), pp. 3–14. [Nachweis im GVK]
| | |
---|
2245 | Ronald de Sousa / Andrea Scarantino: Emotion. In: The Stanford Encyclopedia of
| | |
---|
2246 | Philosophy. Ed. by Edward N. Zalta. Stanford, CA 2018. Article from 25.09.2018. [online]
| | |
---|
2247 | Rachele Sprugnoli / Sara Tonelli / Alessandro Marchetti / Giovanni Moretti:
| | |
---|
2248 | Towards sentiment analysis for historical texts. In: Digital Scholarship in the
| | |
---|
2249 | Humanities 31 (2016), i. 4, pp. 762–772. DOI: 10.1093/llc/fqv027 [Nachweis im GVK]
| | |
---|
2250 | Philip J. Stone / Dexter C. Dunphy / Marshall S. Smith: The General Inquirer: A
| | |
---|
2251 | computer approach to content analysis. In: American Journal of Sociology 73 (1968),
| | |
---|
2252 | i. 5, pp. 634–635. [Nachweis im GVK]
| | |
---|
2253 | Carlo Strapparava / Alessandro Valitutti. WordNet-Affect: An affective extension
| | |
---|
2254 | of WordNet. In: Proceedings of the 4th International Conference on Language Resources
| | |
---|
2255 | and Evaluation. Ed. by Maria Teresa Lino / Maria Francisca Xavier / Fátima Ferreira
| | |
---|
2256 | /
| | |
---|
2257 | Rute Costa / Raquel Silva. 9 volumes. (LREC: 4, Lisbon, 24.-30.05.2004) Paris et al.
| | |
---|
2258 | 2004. Vol. 4, pp. 1083–1086. PDF. [online]
| | |
---|
2259 | [Nachweis im GVK]
| | |
---|
2260 | Jared Suttles / Nancy Ide: Distant supervision for emotion classification with
| | |
---|
2261 | discrete binary values. In: Computational Linguistics and Intelligent Text
| | |
---|
2262 | Processing. Ed. by Alexander Gelbukh. 2 volumes. (CICLing: 14, Samos, 24.-30.03.2013)
| | |
---|
2263 | Berlin et al. 2013. Vol. 2, pp. 121–136. [Nachweis im GVK]
| | |
---|
2264 | Maite Taboada / Mary Ann Gillies / Paul McFetridge: Sentiment classification
| | |
---|
2265 | techniques for tracking literary reputation. In: LREC workshop: Towards computational
| | |
---|
2266 | models of literary analysis. (LREC: 5, Genoa, 22.-28.05.2006) , pp. 36–43. Paris
| | |
---|
2267 | 2006. [online]
| | |
---|
2268 | Maite Taboada / Mary Ann Gillies / Paul McFetridge / Robert Outtrim: Tracking
| | |
---|
2269 | literary reputation with text analysis tools. In: Meeting of the Society for Digital
| | |
---|
2270 | Humanities. Vancouver 2008. PDF. [online]
| | |
---|
2271 | Leo Tolstoy: What is art? And essays on art. Harmondsworth 1962. (= Penguin
| | |
---|
2272 | classics) Siehe auch [Nachweis im GVK]
| | |
---|
2273 | Silvan Tomkins: Affect imagery consciousness. 4 vol. New York, NY et al. 1962.
| | |
---|
2274 | Vol. I: The positive affects. [Nachweis im GVK]
| | |
---|
2275 | Leigh Van Horn: The characters within us: Readers connect with characters to
| | |
---|
2276 | create meaning and understanding. In: Journal of Adolescent & Adult Literacy 40
| | |
---|
2277 | (1997), i. 5, pp. 342–347. [Nachweis im GVK]
| | |
---|
2278 | Edward Vanhoutte: The gates of hell: History and definition of
| | |
---|
2279 | digital|humanities|computing. In: Defining Digital Humanities. A Reader. Ed. by
| | |
---|
2280 | Meliss Terras / Julianne Hyhan / Edward Vanhoutte. Farnham 2013, pp. 119–156.
| | |
---|
2281 | [Nachweis im GVK]
| | |
---|
2282 | Kurt Vonnegut: Kurt Vonnegut at the Blackboard. Ed. by Seven Stories Press. New York,
| | |
---|
2283 | NY 2005.
| | |
---|
2284 | In: Lapham’s Quarterly (2010). Article from 26.03.2010. [online]
| | |
---|
2285 | Bei Yu: An evaluation of text classification methods for literary study. In:
| | |
---|
2286 | Literary and Linguistic Computing 23 (2008), i. 3, pp. 327–343. DOI: 10.1093/llc/fqn015Albin Zehe / Martin Becker / Lena Hettinger / Andreas Hotho / Isabella Reger /
| | |
---|
2287 | Fotis Jannidis: Prediction of happy endings in German novels based on sentiment
| | |
---|
2288 | information. In: Proceedings of the Workshop on Interactions between Data Mining and
| | |
---|
2289 | Natural Language Processing 2016. Ed. by Peggy Cellier / Thierry Charnois / Andreas
| | |
---|
2290 | Hotho / Stan Matwin / Marie-Francine Moens / Yannick Toussaint. (DMNLP: 3, Riva del
| | |
---|
2291 | Garda, 19.-23.09.2016) Aachen 2016, pp. 9–16. URN: urn:nbn:de:0074-1646-4Mikhail Zhuravlev / Irina Golovacheva / Polina de Mauny: Mathematical modelling of
| | |
---|
2292 | love affairs between the characters of the pre-masochistic novel. In: 2014 Second
| | |
---|
2293 | World Conference on Complex Systems (WCCS: 2, Adagir, 10.-12.11.2014) Piscataway,
| | |
---|
2294 | NJ 2014,
| | |
---|
2295 | pp. 396–401. [Nachweis im GVK]
| | |
---|
2296 | Dolf Zillmann / Richard T. Hezel / Norman J. Medoff: The effect of affective
| | |
---|
2297 | states on selective exposure to televised entertainment fare. In: Journal of Applied
| | |
---|
2298 | Social Psychology 10 (1980), i. 4, pp. 323–339. [Nachweis im GVK]
| | |
---|
2299 |
| | |
---|
2300 |
| | |
---|
2301 |
| | |
---|
2302 |
| | |
---|
2303 | List of Figures with Captions
| | |
---|
2304 |
| | |
---|
2305 |
| | |
---|
2306 | Fig. 1: Plutchik’s wheel of emotions. [Plutchik 2011.
| | |
---|
2307 | PD]
| | |
---|
2308 |
| | |
---|
2309 |
| | |
---|
2310 | Fig. 2: Circumplex model of affect: Horizontal axis represents the valence dimension,
| | |
---|
2311 | the vertical axis represents the arousal dimension. Drawn after Posner et al. 2005. [Kim / Klinger 2019]
| | |
---|
2312 |
| | |
---|
2313 |
| | |
---|
2314 | Tab. 3: Summary of characteristics of methods used in the papers reviewed
| | |
---|
2315 | in this survey. Download as PDF. [Kim / Klinger 2019]
| | |
---|
2316 |
| | |
---|